Overview · Filed: —
ACT_17434/2024
JUICE EXTRACTION MODULE FOR JUICER
InfringementMain Infringement ActionParis LDInfringement Action—
Parties
Claimants
- Hurom Co., Ltd.
Reps:
Respondents
- NUC Electronics Europe GmbH
- NUC Electronics Co., Ltd
- WARMCOOK
Reps:
Judges
French-seated division — individual judges anonymized.
- Panel member (anonymized)Presiding judge and judge-rapporteur
- Panel member (anonymized)Legally qualified judge
- Panel member (anonymized)Legally qualified judge
- Panel member (anonymized)Technically qualified judge
Patents
- EP 3 155 936
CPC codes: A47J19/025, A47J19/06, A47J43/0716
Technology area: Consumer Goods · Kitchen Appliances
Sector: Furniture & Household
Outcome
RevokedDismissed — patent invalid
Filed: —
First decided: May 23, 2025
Language: —
Paris Local Division revoked the Dutch, French, German and Italian parts of claims 1-6 of EP 3 155 936 (Hurom slow juicer) as unconditionally amended in the Main Request, and claims 1-3 as amended in the Auxiliary Request, following NUC Electronics' counterclaim for revocation. The patent was found invalid under Art. 138(1) EPC. All of Hurom's infringement claims were dismissed. Hurom's claims for infringement in Poland were held admissible (BSH v Electrolux principle) but dismissed on the merits for lack of evidence. Hurom was ordered to bear all costs.
Claims
At issue1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Revoked1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Notes: Paris Local Division revoked claims 1-6 of EP 3 155 936 as per Main Request (Dutch/French/German/Italian parts) and claims 1-3 as per Auxiliary Request; all infringement claims dismissed; operative part explicitly names claims 1 to 6.