UPC APP 27069/2025
—·EP3356109: FOAM RESIN STRUCTURAL PART FOR A FRAME OF A VEHICLE AND PRODUCTION METHOD THEREFOR
- Case details
- Status—ActionProcedural applicationCategoryOther Procedural
- Parties
- ClaimantsReps: Dirk Jestaed (Krieger Mes & Graf von der Groeben Partnerschaft mbB)
- Division
- Court of Appeal
- Judges
- Rian Kalden · Presiding judge
- Ingeborg Simonsson · Legally qualified judge
- Patricia Rombach · Legally qualified judge and judge-rapporteur
- Marc van der Burg · Technically qualified judge
- Erwin Wismeth · Technically qualified judge
- Language
- —
- First decided
- Jun 17, 2025
- 2025-06-17Generic application
The Court of Appeal declared inadmissible Knaus Tabbert AG's 'Gegenvorstellung' (objection to the rejection of its stay application under R. 223 RoP), holding that a mere challenge to the reasoning of the appellate order denying a suspensive effect does not constitute an admissible procedural remedy, and that new facts about third parties' financial situation that could have been raised at first instance are not admissible.
Legal issues:Admissibility of 'Gegenvorstellung' against refusal of suspensive effect under R. 223 RoPAdmissibility of new facts in appellate proceedingsSuspensive effect of appeal - 2025-06-17DismissedGeneric application
The Court of Appeal (Panel 2) declared inadmissible Knaus Tabbert AG's 'Gegenvorstellung' (objection) filed against the Court of Appeal's earlier rejection of Knaus Tabbert's application for suspensive effect (R.223 RoP). The Court held that an objection which merely challenges the Court of Appeal's legal opinion expressed in the order rejecting a suspensive effect application is inadmissible. The infringement action by Yellow Sphere Innovations GmbH and Erwin Härtwich regarding EP 3 356 109 (vehicle frame with foam resin structural part) continues.
Legal issues:Admissibility of objection ('Gegenvorstellung') against Court of Appeal orderApplication for suspensive effect under R.223 RoPRight to effective remedy under Art.47 EU Charter
- 0F4E4483168404E4665991BC92C18D37_de.pdf2025-06-17DE
- orderobjectionEN.17.06pdf.pdf2025-06-17GERMAN