UPC Analytics
ENDE
Overview · Filed: Sep 10, 2025

UPC_APP_35643/2025

HERBICIDE COMPOSITIONS

Procedural & sub-applicationsDocument Access (RoP262)Court of AppealGenericCase Closed
Parties

Claimants

  • Docket Navigator
Reps: Thomas Oliver (Powell Gilbert)

Respondents

  • Sumi Agro Europe Limited
  • Syngenta Limited
Reps: Gareth Williams (Marks & Clerk LLP); Jörn Peters (Casalonga)
Judges
  • Rian Kalden
  • Ingeborg Simonsson
  • Patricia Rombach
Patents
  • EP2152073
  • EP 2 152 073
CPC codes: A01N25/22, A01N41/10, A01N37/02, A01N37/06, A01N47/36

Sector: Agriculture

Outcome
Dismissed
Filed: Sep 10, 2025
First decided: Dec 19, 2025
Language: English

The Court of Appeal dismissed Docket Navigator's application for access to written pleadings and evidence in the Sumi Agro v. Syngenta proceedings (UPC_CoA_523/2024) under R. 262.1(b) RoP. The Court held that granting access to a commercial patent intelligence platform intending to republish documents to its subscribers is not an interest protected under Art. 45 UPCA. Copyright is not a general interest to be considered under Art. 45 UPCA. The requirement of representation and the proper conduct of proceedings would be compromised by granting access for commercial redistribution purposes.

Open on UPC Registry