UPClytics
View all cases

UPC APP 6601/2024

·EP4108782 +1 more: COMPOSITIONS AND METHODS FOR ANALYTE DETECTION

Case details
Status
Action
Procedural application
Category
Other Procedural
Parties
Claimants
Reps: Tilman Müller-Stoy (Bardehle Pagenberg)
Division
Court of Appeal
Judges
Technology
Biotechnology
Language
First decided
Feb 26, 2024
Decisions
  • 2024-02-26
    Generic application

    The Court of Appeal of the UPC refused to stay the provisional measures appeal proceedings despite NanoString's Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing in the US. The court held that even if the insolvency threshold under R. 311.1 RoP was met, no stay was warranted where the oral proceedings were already concluded and the case was ready for decision, balancing procedural economy and cost efficiency under Art. 41(3) UPCA.

    Legal issues:Stay of proceedings upon insolvency (R. 311.1 RoP)Chapter 11 bankruptcy as insolvency under UPC RulesProcedural economy and fair balance of interests (Art. 41(3) UPCA)Appeal against provisional measures order
  • 2024-02-26
    Appeal decisionGeneric application

    Court of Appeal order declining to stay the provisional measures appeal proceedings following NanoString's insolvency (Chapter 11 bankruptcy under US law). The Court held that under R. 311(1) RoP, proceedings need not be stayed when a party is declared insolvent after the close of oral argument if the case is ready for decision, as principles of procedural economy, cost-efficiency and a fair balance between party interests (Art. 41(3) UPCA) support proceeding to judgment. US Chapter 11 proceedings qualified as insolvency under the applicable lex fori concursus.

    Legal issues:Stay of proceedings upon insolvency (R. 311 RoP)US Chapter 11 bankruptcy as insolvencyProcedural economy and cost-efficiency (Art. 41(3) UPCA)Lex fori concursus
Documents
  • 6601-Anordnung%20-%20AussetzungEN.final_.pdf2024-02-26EN
  • D5A5F1036516DBC40DE6FD277F5BE1D0_de.pdf2024-02-26GERMAN
10x Genomics, Inc. v NanoString Technologies Inc. — UPC APP 6601/2024 | UPClytics