UPClytics
View all cases

UPC CFI 2246/2025

·EP3944587 +1 more: Telecommunications network and method for time-based network access

Case details
Status
Action
Infringement
Category
Main Infringement Action
Division
The Hague LD
Judges
Technology
Telecommunications
Language
First decided
Apr 14, 2026
Last decision
Jun 2, 2026
Decisions
  • 2026-06-02
    Infringement Action

    The Judge-Rapporteur granted the parties' joint request to vary the order of 28 May 2026. The variations concern the scope of licence documents to be disclosed by Claimant to Defendants' external counsel and extend the deadline for the Statement of Defence to 11 September 2026.

    Legal issues:Variation of procedural order (R. 335 RoP)Scope of licence disclosure obligationExtension of Statement of Defence deadline
  • 2026-05-28
    Infringement Action

    The Court issued an order governing the exchange of licenses and confidentiality arrangements for the disclosure of KPN's smartphone manufacturer licenses since 2015, including specific rules for Apple confidential documents. The order resolves outstanding disputes on disclosure scope, confidentiality club membership, the applicable confidentiality regime mirroring the LG Düsseldorf proceedings, and sets the deadline for the Defendants' Statement of Defence at three months and five weeks from the order date.

    Legal issues:Disclosure of FRAND license agreements to defendants' external counsel and expertsConfidentiality club arrangements and access controls for disclosed licensesMirroring of access and confidentiality regime from parallel LG Düsseldorf proceedingsProcedure for Apple third-party objections to expert access to Apple DocumentsTimeline for Statement of Defence in context of phased license disclosurePotential access by in-house defendants' employees to disclosed materials
  • 2026-04-14
    Infringement Action

    The Court issued an order on a jointly requested procedural matter governing the exchange of KPN's licence agreements to defendants' counsel and external experts, subject to a confidentiality regime mirrored from parallel LG Düsseldorf proceedings. The Court accepted the joint request without modification and directed parties to submit availability for a forthcoming case management hearing.

    Legal issues:Exchange of licence agreements to defendants' counsel and external expertsConfidentiality regime for disclosed licence agreementsMirroring of access conditions from parallel LG Düsseldorf proceedingsPenalty for contravention of confidentiality obligations (up to €250,000 per contravention)
Documents
  • order%202246-2025%20KPN%20-%20Oleading%20et%20al%20-%20III%20exchange%20of%20licences%20and%20confidentiality%20-%20signed.pdf2026-04-14EN
  • final%20order%202246-2025%20KPN%20-%20Oleading%20et%20al%20-%20III%20exchange%20of%20licences%20and%20confidentiality%20REDACTED.pdf2026-05-28EN
  • variation%20order%202246-2025%20KPN%20-%20Oleading%20et%20al%20-%20III%20exchange%20of%20licences%20and%20confidentiality%20%28REDACTED%29.pdf2026-06-02EN