UPC_CFI_355/2023
LITHOGRAPHIC PRINTING PLATE ORIGINAL PLATE, AND METHOD FOR PRODUCING LITHOGRAPHIC PRINTING PLATE
Claimants
- FUJIFILM Corporation(Fujifilm Group)
Respondents
- Kodak GmbH(Kodak Group)
- Kodak Graphic Communications GmbH(Kodak Group)
- Kodak Holding GmbH(Kodak Group)
- Ronny Thomas
- Berenice Thom
- Rute Lopes
- Stefanie Parchmann
- EP3594009
- EP 3 594 009 B1
Technology area: Industrial Manufacturing · Printing Technology
Decision of the Düsseldorf Local Division dated 28 January 2025 in infringement action by FUJIFILM Corporation against Kodak entities regarding EP 3 594 009 B1 (printing plate technology). The court rejected Kodak's preliminary objection, then upheld the counterclaim for revocation, revoking EP 3 594 009 B1 in all Contracting Member States where it has effect, on grounds including added matter (Art. 123(2) EPC) and obviousness over prior art. FUJIFILM's application to amend the patent was dismissed. As a consequence, the infringement action was also dismissed. The court confirmed jurisdiction over the UK part of the patent despite the revocation counterclaim concerning the German part, applying long-arm jurisdiction principles. Costs were ordered against the claimant. Value in dispute: EUR 15,000,000 each for infringement action and counterclaim for revocation.
Open on UPC Registry