UPClytics
View all cases

UPC CFI 495/2023

Dec 28, 2023·EP3000239 · SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR UNIVERSAL CONTROL OF ELECTRONIC DEVICES

Case details
Status
Case Closed (Withdrawn)
Action
Infringement
Category
Main infringement action
Parties
Claimants
Representatives
Respondents
Representatives
Division
Paris LD
Technology
  • Electrical engineering
    Telecommunications · Computer technology
Language
English
First decided
Feb 12, 2024
Last decision
Feb 28, 2024
How this compares
The court's record for this kind of case, counted in first-instance rulings. A figure in brackets is the number of rulings a rate rests on.
Infringement foundMedian days to first decision
All UPC53% (62/117)124
Paris LDLockedLocked
Judge Camille LignièresLockedLocked
Judge Petri RinkinenLockedLocked
Judge Carine GilletLockedLocked
Judge Andrea Perronace—Locked

At the UPC: ICPillar LLC (7 cases)·ARM Limited (7 cases)

This dispute contains 4 other proceedings

UPC CoA 301/2024·UPC APP 5858/2024·UPC APP 61630/2024·UPC APP 8330/2024

1 other defendants litigating the same or a related patent

UPC CoA 312/2024

Start a free trial to see how each one ended.

More cases: Paris LD·2023

Decisions
  • —
    infringement

    Summary: 1. The withdrawal of ICPillar's infringement claim as regards all defendants is permitted. 2. The withdrawal of ARM's counterclaim for revocation as regards the Claimant is permitted. 3. The proceedings in UPC_CFI_495/2023 ACT_596432/2023 are closed

Documents
Document titleDatePublic
Case Closure Formal Check2025-02-24Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2024-12-13Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-12-13Not public
final decision2024-12-13Public
Receipt2024-11-22Not public
Application to Withdraw Counterclaim Rule 265 ROP2024-11-22Not public
Receipt2024-11-19Not public
15332-00101-241119-R.265 R370 signe2024-11-19Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-10-16Not public
Stay Order2024-10-16Public
Receipt2024-10-15Not public
15332-00101-241014-R295 vF A signed2024-10-14Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-09-30Not public
Order R 9.32024-09-30Public
Receipt2024-09-26Not public
15332-00101-240925-R9 A signed2024-09-26Not public
Receipt2024-09-03Not public
Receipt2024-09-03Not public
Receipt2024-09-03Not public
Exhibit CC 402024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 332024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 382024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 342024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 362024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 412024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 402024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 392024-09-02Not public
Reply to Defence to Counterclaim2024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 422024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 372024-09-02Not public
Exhibit CC 352024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 152024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 142024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 122024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 132024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 122024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 112024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 172024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 102024-09-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 162024-09-02Not public
Rejoinder to the reply to the statement of defence2024-09-02Not public
Defence to Application to Amend the Patent2024-09-02Not public
Receipt2024-08-22Not public
C20 NIC-400 Paper2024-08-22Not public
V3 Wikipedia page of GDSII2024-08-22Not public
V2 Affidavit of Joseph C. McAlexander III2024-08-22Not public
Cover letter Rule 9 Reply SoD A signed2024-08-22Not public
Answer to CC and SoD signed2024-08-22Not public
AR1 Auxiliary request No 12024-08-22Not public
AR3 Auxiliary request No 32024-08-22Not public
P12 Written opinion European Examination2024-08-22Not public
V1 A practitioner s guide to European Patent Law Paul England2024-08-22Not public
AR2 Auxiliary request No 22024-08-22Not public
C22 arm flexible access data sheet2024-08-22Not public
C21 Affidavit of Professor Homayoun2024-08-22Not public
Receipt2024-07-16Not public
Receipt2024-07-16Not public
Answer to CC and SoD signed2024-07-03Not public
Application to communicate information pursuant to rule 191 rop2024-07-03Not public
AR1 Auxiliary request No 12024-07-03Not public
AR3 Auxiliary request No 32024-07-03Not public
AR2 Auxiliary request No 22024-07-03Not public
Application to amend the patent2024-07-03Not public
Order set the dates IC and OH- ICPillar v Arm2024-06-05Public
Outcome of the Order2024-05-30Not public
Order grant a leave to appeal2024-05-30Public
Receipt2024-05-29Not public
15332-00101-240528 - Leave for appeal2024-05-29Not public
RoP9 - Exhibit 1 - 15332-00101-240521-Order security for costs2024-05-29Not public
RoP 9 - Exhibit 2 - Legal expenses insurance policy and endorsement2024-05-29Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-05-21Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-05-21Not public
Security for costs Order Arm v ICPILLAR2024-05-21Public
Exhibit 5: Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property and Signatories2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 1: Declaration of Mohsin Patel2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 3: UPC_CFI_514/2013 (LD Munich) Order of 23/04/2024, Volkswagen AG and a. v. Network System Technologies LLC2024-05-14Not public
15332-00101-240514-Written observations on application for security for costs2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 2: UPC_CFI_15/2023 (LD Munich) Order of 29/09/2023, Edwards Lifesciences Corporation v. Meril GmbH2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 2: UPC_CFI_15/2023 (LD Munich) Order of 29/09/2023, Edwards Lifesciences Corporation v. Meril GmbH2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 6: UPC_CFI_239/2023 (LD The Hague) Order of 13/02/2024, Arkyne Technologies S.L. v. Plant-e Knowledge2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 4: Delaware Division of Corporations Website - ICPILLAR LLC and 2023 Delaware Code Title 8 Chapter I subchapter2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 8: UPC_CFI_252/2023 (CD Munich) Order of 30/10/2023, President and Fellows of Harvard College v. NanoString Tech2024-05-14Not public
Exhibit 7: Response to the application to withdraw Allinea Software GmbH filed by Arm’s representative, 21/03/20242024-05-14Not public
Statement of Defense2024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 12024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 42024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 32024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 22024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD72024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 92024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 52024-05-02Not public
Statement of Defense2024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 62024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 52024-05-02Not public
Exhibit SoD 82024-05-02Not public
PO written comments security for costs2024-04-29Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-04-29Not public
Order R.9.3 request2024-04-29Public
Receipt2024-04-29Not public
Exhibit SoD 12024-04-27Not public
Exhibit SoD 22024-04-27Not public
Statement of Defense2024-04-27Not public
Application Rule 92024-04-27Not public
Statement of Defense2024-04-27Not public
Statement of Defense2024-04-26Not public
Statement of Defense2024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 12024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 12024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 42024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 22024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD72024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 32024-04-26Not public
Statement of Defense2024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 82024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 62024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 92024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 52024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 52024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 32024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD12024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 92024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 82024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 42024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 22024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 52024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 62024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 72024-04-26Not public
Statement of Defense2024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 72024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 52024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 22024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 42024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 32024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 82024-04-26Not public
Statement of Defense2024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 52024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD12024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 62024-04-26Not public
Exhibit SoD 92024-04-26Not public
Receipt2024-04-26Not public
Exhibit MB D12024-04-26Not public
Exhibit MB D22024-04-26Not public
Exhibit MB D42024-04-26Not public
Exhibit MB D32024-04-26Not public
Application for Security for Costs2024-04-26Not public
Preliminary_Objection_DecisionOutcome2024-04-11Not public
PO Order Arm v ICPillar 11 April 20242024-04-11Public
Outcome of the Order2024-03-22Not public
Order Withdrawal Allinea2024-03-22Public
commentPreliminaryObjection2024-03-21Not public
P2 Extract Arm website Company Global Offices2024-03-21Not public
P7 Extract LinkedIn website Senior Software Engineer2024-03-21Not public
P3 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Distributors2024-03-21Not public
15332-00101-240321- Answer PO2-3 signed2024-03-21Not public
P11 The present submissions with revisions marks emphasize in margin2024-03-21Not public
C17 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Arm Socratres2024-03-21Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-21Not public
P10 Building the Future of Computing Arm2024-03-21Not public
P5 Central Division Munich Amgen c Sanofi Order 24 August 20232024-03-21Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-21Not public
P6 Extract Careers Arm Website Galway Office2024-03-21Not public
P1a Contact Us Arm Flexible Access Inquiry (new)2024-03-21Not public
P8 Central Division Paris Edwards v Meril Order 13 November 20232024-03-21Not public
P9 ARM Poland with profile of their board members McElroy and Gill2024-03-21Not public
C01 Extract Arm Socrates User guide version 1 52024-03-21Not public
X05 ARM limited subsidiaries from GOV UK companies register website and Orbis register website A2024-03-21Not public
commentPreliminaryObjection2024-03-21Not public
P10 Building the Future of Computing Arm2024-03-21Not public
C17 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Arm Socratres2024-03-21Not public
P11 The present submissions with revisions marks emphasize in margin2024-03-21Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-21Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-21Not public
P2 Extract Arm website Company Global Offices2024-03-21Not public
P3 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Distributors2024-03-21Not public
P7 Extract LinkedIn website Senior Software Engineer2024-03-21Not public
P5 Central Division Munich Amgen c Sanofi Order 24 August 20232024-03-21Not public
15332-00101-240321- Answer PO2-3 signed2024-03-21Not public
P6 Extract Careers Arm Website Galway Office2024-03-21Not public
P1a Contact Us Arm Flexible Access Inquiry (new)2024-03-21Not public
P9 ARM Poland with profile of their board members McElroy and Gill2024-03-21Not public
X05 ARM limited subsidiaries from GOV UK companies register website and Orbis register website A2024-03-21Not public
C01 Extract Arm Socrates User guide version 1 52024-03-21Not public
P8 Central Division Paris Edwards v Meril Order 13 November 20232024-03-21Not public
Response to withdrawal Allinea Software GmbH2024-03-21Not public
PO comments withdrawal application Allinea2024-03-14Not public
Receipt2024-03-14Not public
Application for technically qualified judge2024-03-13Not public
Receipt2024-03-13Not public
commentPreliminaryObjection2024-03-12Not public
P8 Central Division Paris Edwards v Meril Order 13 November 20232024-03-12Not public
C17 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Arm Socratres2024-03-12Not public
15332-00101-240312- Comments PO A signed2024-03-12Not public
X05 ARM limited subsidiaries from GOV UK companies register website and Orbis register website A2024-03-12Not public
P2 Extract Arm website Company Global Offices2024-03-12Not public
P3 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Distributors2024-03-12Not public
P7 Extract LinkedIn website Senior Software Engineer2024-03-12Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-12Not public
P1 Extract Arm website Contact Us Arm Flexible Access Inquiry2024-03-12Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-12Not public
P6 Extract Careers Arm Website Galway Office2024-03-12Not public
P5 Central Division Munich Amgen c Sanofi Order 24 August 20232024-03-12Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-12Not public
P4 Cour de cassation Chambre civile 1 29 juin 20222024-03-12Not public
P3 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Distributors2024-03-12Not public
P1 Extract Arm website Contact Us Arm Flexible Access Inquiry2024-03-12Not public
P2 Extract Arm website Company Global Offices2024-03-12Not public
15332-00101-240312- Comments PO A signed2024-03-12Not public
C17 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Arm Socratres2024-03-12Not public
P7 Extract LinkedIn website Senior Software Engineer2024-03-12Not public
P8 Central Division Paris Edwards v Meril Order 13 November 20232024-03-12Not public
X05 ARM limited subsidiaries from GOV UK companies register website and Orbis register website A2024-03-12Not public
P6 Extract Careers Arm Website Galway Office2024-03-12Not public
P5 Central Division Munich Amgen c Sanofi Order 24 August 20232024-03-12Not public
15332-00101-240312- Application request R265 R9 A signed2024-03-12Not public
Exhibit 1 Copy of an official printout of the German Commercial Register including an English translation Exhibit MB 32024-03-12Not public
X05 ARM limited subsidiaries from GOV UK companies register website and Orbis register website A2024-03-12Not public
Confirmation of notification of appointment2024-03-12Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case - 12131/20242024-03-12Not public
preliminaryObjection2024-03-07Not public
Exhibit MB C22024-03-07Not public
Preliminary Objection SVF HoldCo2024-03-07Not public
Exhibit MB C22024-03-07Not public
Exhibit MB C12024-03-07Not public
preliminaryObjection2024-03-07Not public
Exhibit MB B12024-03-06Not public
Exhibit MB B22024-03-06Not public
Exhibit MB B22024-03-06Not public
Preliminary Objection2024-03-06Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-03-05Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-03-04Not public
Notification Of Service2024-03-01Not public
Order RoP 275-22024-03-01Not public
Notification Of Service2024-03-01Not public
Order RoP 275-22024-03-01Not public
Notification Of Service2024-03-01Not public
Order RoP 275-22024-03-01Not public
Notification Of Service2024-03-01Not public
Order R275-22024-03-01Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-29Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-29Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-29Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-02-28Not public
Order R.275.2 ICPillar alternative method Service2024-02-28Public
Outcome of the Order2024-02-28Not public
Order request withdrawal R 265 ICPillar against one of the defendants before service of SoC2024-02-28Public
Template-Order2024-02-28Not public
preliminaryObjection2024-02-27Not public
Preliminary Objection2024-02-26Not public
Exhibit MB 22024-02-26Not public
Exhibit MB 12024-02-26Not public
Exhibit MB 42024-02-26Not public
Exhibit MB 32024-02-26Not public
Receipt2024-02-26Not public
X05 ARM limited subsidiaries from GOV UK companies register website and Orbis register website A2024-02-26Not public
15332-00101-240226- Application request R265 R9(5945980.2) A sign2024-02-26Not public
copie ecran DHL A2024-02-26Not public
Receipt2024-02-20Not public
Exhibit 1 - Order 12 Feb 24 ICPillar R 275.1 signed CL2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 2 - Bailiff report ARM Limited2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 3 - Bailiff report APICAL LIMITED2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 4 - Bailiff report SIMULITY LABS LIMITED2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 2 - Bailiff report ARM Limited2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 5 - Bailiff report SVF HOLDCO2024-02-15Not public
Application request R275.2 PDF A2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 3 - Bailiff report APICAL LIMITED2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 4 - Bailiff report SIMULITY LABS LIMITED2024-02-15Not public
Exhibit 5 - Bailiff report SVF HOLDCO2024-02-15Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-14Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-14Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-13Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-13Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-13Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-13Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-13Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-13Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-02-12Not public
Order ICPILLAR R. 275.12024-02-12Public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-02-02Not public
Receipt2024-02-02Not public
Notification Of Service2024-02-02Not public
AR Arm Sweden AB2024-02-02Not public
15332-00101-240201 - request R275_1 A signed2024-02-01Not public
EN-2023-12-08-ld-Mannheim-App_589186_2023 A2024-02-01Not public
Notification Of Service2024-01-26Not public
AR2024-01-26Not public
Notification Of Service2024-01-26Not public
AR2024-01-26Not public
AR2024-01-26Not public
Notification Of Service2024-01-26Not public
Notification Of Service2024-01-26Not public
AR2024-01-26Not public
Notification Of Service2024-01-26Not public
AR2024-01-26Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-15Not public
epoUploadDocumentsWorkflow2024-01-08Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-01-08Not public
Document from EPO2024-01-03Not public
EPO-Request-for-case-pending2023-12-29Not public
Receipt2023-12-29Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2023-12-29Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-12-22Not public
C11 Extract Arm Developer Video2023-12-22Not public
C05 Arm CoreLink NIC-450 Network Interconnect Technical Overview2023-12-22Not public
X07 Extract Arm website Job Offer Senior Partner Manager Southern Europe2023-12-22Not public
C10 Extract Arm Developer Website Use Software Components2023-12-22Not public
C02 Extract Arm website Build a Secure IoT System on Chip2023-12-22Not public
C19 ARM Tech Symposia China 2015 On the road to designing a system in a day with ARM IP tooling2023-12-22Not public
P09 EP14800934 register extract2023-12-22Not public
14733 00101 231222 Statement of claims vF 5873814 4 A signe2023-12-22Not public
P08 International search report of PCT application PCTUS20140393022023-12-22Not public
C08 Extract Arm Developer Website Developmement Studio Components2023-12-22Not public
C12 Extract Youtube Video n22023-12-22Not public
P11 Confirmation of Assignment for ICPillar A2023-12-22Not public
P04 US Patent application US20140351774A12023-12-22Not public
X02 About Arm Company Information Benefits History2023-12-22Not public
C09 Arm Developer website Vision User s Guide Setup the Project2023-12-22Not public
C01 Extract Arm Socrates User guide version 1 52023-12-22Not public
C13 Extract Arm website Products CoreLink PCK 6002023-12-22Not public
P05 US Patent application US20150121320A12023-12-22Not public
C06 Extract Arm Developer website About CoreLinkCreator2023-12-22Not public
C17 Extract Arm website Development Tools and Software Arm Socratres2023-12-22Not public
P01 Patent EP3000239B12023-12-22Not public
P02 Patent application EP4164239A12023-12-22Not public
X04 Extract Arm website New ARM IP Tooling2023-12-22Not public
C16 Extract Arm Developer website Corstone 1000 Technical Specifications2023-12-22Not public
P07 PCT Patent application WO2014190242A12023-12-22Not public
P06 US Patent application US20170139406A12023-12-22Not public
C03 Extract YouTube Video n12023-12-22Not public
C07 Extract Arm Developer website Project Explorer2023-12-22Not public
P10 European search report of EP patent application 222118012023-12-22Not public
X01 Extract Arm website The official history of Arm2023-12-22Not public
C18 Extract Arm website Suppliers2023-12-22Not public
C15 Extract Arm website Arm GPUs for Graphics Processing All the Products2023-12-22Not public
X06 Extract Arm website Sophia Antipolis Office2023-12-22Not public
X03 Article eCompetitions2023-12-22Not public
X05 ARM limited subsidiaries from GOV UK companies register website and Orbis register website A2023-12-22Not public
C14 Extract Arm website Products CoreLink Generic Interrupt Controller GIC2023-12-22Not public
P03 Extract Wikipedia website Integrated Circuit Internet of things System on a chip2023-12-22Not public
C04 Extract Arm Community blog System Assembly through Intelligent Configuration2023-12-22Not public