UPClytics
View all cases

UPC CoA 540/2024

Sep 19, 2024·EP3685783: ENDOLUMINAL LASER ABLATION DEVICE FOR TREATING VEINS

Case details
Status
Case Closed
Action
Appeal
Category
Main Appeal
Parties
Claimants
Reps: Paul Szynka (CBH Rechtsanwälte); Hannes Jacobsen (CBH Rechtsanwälte); Alexander M. Fischer (CBH Rechtsanwälte); Franz Herrmann (Dendorfer & Herrmann)
Respondents
Reps: Jörg Schmidt (Wildanger Kehrwald Graf von Schwerin & Partner mbB); Jan Caspar Maiers (Wildanger Kehrwald Graf von Schwerin & Partner mbB)
Division
Court of Appeal
Technology
Pharmaceutical & Medical
Language
First decided
Feb 24, 2025
Decisions
  • 2025-02-24
    PI deniedAppeal decisionAppeal RoP220.1

    Court of Appeal rejected Biolitec's appeal against the Düsseldorf Local Division's refusal to grant a preliminary injunction. The CoA upheld the first-instance order, finding that Biolitec had not demonstrated the necessity of provisional measures: proceedings on the merits could be awaited; the status quo on the market had existed for years before the patent was granted; and Biolitec failed to demonstrate sufficient evidence of urgency regarding stocking or tender-related harm. Biolitec was ordered to bear the costs of the appeal proceedings.

    Legal issues:Provisional measures necessity test (Art.62 UPCA, R.206, R.211 RoP)Weighing parties' interests and time factorStatus quo on market predating patent grantEvidence of stocking and tender-related harm
  • 2025-02-24
    PI deniedAppeal decisionAppeal RoP220.1

    German-language signed version of the Court of Appeal order rejecting Biolitec's appeal in the provisional measures proceedings against Light Guide Optics and SIA LIGHTGUIDE International. Identical in substance to the English version: appeal rejected, Biolitec ordered to bear costs. The provisional injunction was denied because proceedings on the merits could be awaited and necessity was not demonstrated.

    Legal issues:Provisional measures necessity test (Art.62 UPCA, R.206, R.211 RoP)Necessity of provisional measures versus awaiting merits decisionStatus quo on market
Documents
Document titleDatePublic
Order2026-03-27Not public
action.communication.general2026-03-18Not public
Receipt2026-03-16Not public
Cover sheet2026-03-16Not public
Application Appellant2026-03-16Not public
Case Closure Formal Check2025-08-29Not public
Order2025-02-24Public
Hearing reference2025-02-11Not public
Hearing reference2025-02-11Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-01-16Not public
procedural order2025-01-16Public
procedural order2025-01-16Not public
Receipt2025-01-15Not public
Antrag auf Teilnahme per Videokonferenz2025-01-15Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-12-09Not public
Procedural Order2024-12-09Public
Receipt2024-12-09Not public
20241209_Biolitec_vs_Light_Guide_Antrag_Videokonferenz_Krauklis_Luetzler.pdf2024-12-09Not public
Interim-Procedure-Closure2024-12-09Not public
Summon-Oral-Hearing2024-12-05Not public
Procedural Order2024-12-05Public
Interim-Conference-Decision2024-12-05Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-12-05Not public
Procedural Order2024-12-05Public
Receipt2024-12-02Not public
R.9-Antrag auf Stellungnahmefrist2024-11-29Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-11-21Not public
WKS_09 Änderungen Anspruch 12024-11-21Not public
WKS_D12_DE10393938T52024-11-21Not public
WKS_D9_US2007106286A12024-11-21Not public
WKS 04 US4842390A2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D17_Spaniol_et.al.2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D26_US55374992024-11-21Not public
WKS 07 Stammanmeldung 1 EP2620119A22024-11-21Not public
WKS_D18_Buchholz_et.al.2024-11-21Not public
WKS 03 Merkmalsgliederung2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D17a._Spaniol_et.al.2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D15_EP0232511A12024-11-21Not public
WKS_D8_DE19739456B42024-11-21Not public
WKS 12 Erteilungsabsicht 22.05.20242024-11-21Not public
WKS10 Zeugenaussage Heinz Büchel 20.11.20242024-11-21Not public
WKS_D19_EP0514258A12024-11-21Not public
WKS 02 Gegenüberstellung Anspruchswortlaut2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D24_US5354294A2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D20_WO2007058891A22024-11-21Not public
WKS 08 Stammanmeldung 2 EP2620119A22024-11-21Not public
WKS_D22_CA2099452A12024-11-21Not public
WKS_P1_US67537P2024-11-21Not public
WKS 05 Technische Zeichnung.pdf2024-11-21Not public
20241121 Berufungserwiderung2024-11-21Not public
WKS 01 Inhaltsverzeichnis2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D21_US2008065058A12024-11-21Not public
WKS_D25_WO080732642024-11-21Not public
WKS_D14_EP1862141A12024-11-21Not public
WKS 11 Wettbewerbsprodukte2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D10_US6113589A2024-11-21Not public
WKS_D16_EP0959783B12024-11-21Not public
WKS 06 Stammanmeldung 0 EP2974687A12024-11-21Not public
WKS 13 Erteilungsbeschluss2024-11-21Not public
WKS D0b EP3685783A12024-11-21Not public
WKS_D23_EP0689797A12024-11-21Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-11-21Not public
WKS 08 Stammanmeldung 2 EP2620119A2.pdf2024-11-21Not public
WKS 09 Änderungen Anspruch 12024-11-21Not public
WKS D9 US2007106286A12024-11-21Not public
WKS D17 Spaniol et al.2024-11-21Not public
WKS 11 Wettbewerbsprodukte2024-11-21Not public
WKS 01 Inhaltsverzeichnis2024-11-21Not public
WKS P1 US67537P2024-11-21Not public
WKS D17a Spaniol et al.2024-11-21Not public
20241121 Berufungserwiderung2024-11-21Not public
WKS D23 EP0689797A12024-11-21Not public
WKS D20 WO2007058891A22024-11-21Not public
WKS D8 DE19739456B42024-11-21Not public
WKS D22 CA2099452A12024-11-21Not public
WKS D24 US5354294A2024-11-21Not public
WKS D0b EP3685783A12024-11-21Not public
WKS D10 US6113589A2024-11-21Not public
WKS D25 WO080732642024-11-21Not public
WKS D19 EP0514258A12024-11-21Not public
WKS 13 Erteilungsbeschluss2024-11-21Not public
WKS 10 Zeugenaussage Heinz Büchel 20.11.20242024-11-21Not public
WKS D21 US2008065058A12024-11-21Not public
WKS D26 US55374992024-11-21Not public
WKS D15 EP0232511A12024-11-21Not public
WKS 12 Erteilungsabsicht EPA 22.05.20242024-11-21Not public
WKS D16 EP0959783B12024-11-21Not public
WKS 02 Gegenüberstellung Anspruchswortlaut2024-11-21Not public
WKS 06 Stammanmeldung 0 EP2974687A12024-11-21Not public
WKS D14 EP1862141A12024-11-21Not public
WKS D12 DE10393938T52024-11-21Not public
WKS D18 Buchholz et al.2024-11-21Not public
WKS 03 Merkmalsgliederung2024-11-21Not public
WKS 07 Stammanmeldung 1 EP2620119A22024-11-21Not public
WKS 05 Technische Zeichnung2024-11-21Not public
WKS 04 US4842390A2024-11-21Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-11-07Not public
20241107_Application_re_address_for_service2024-11-07Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-11-05Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-11-05Not public
PROCEDURAL ORDER2024-11-05Public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-11-04Not public
Receipt2024-11-04Not public
20241104_biolitec-LGO_Fristverlängerungsantrag_LGOI2024-11-04Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-11-01Not public
PROCEDURAL ORDER2024-11-01Public
Receipt2024-10-31Not public
20241030_biolitec-LGO_Fristverlängerungsantrag2024-10-31Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-10-16Not public
Receipt2024-10-16Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-10-16Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-10-16Not public
Anlage CBH 52 - Tabelle Formal Checks2024-10-01Not public
Anlage CBH 53 - Überweisungsbeleg2024-10-01Not public
Berufung und Berufungsbegründung - CBH v. 19.09.20242024-10-01Not public
Stellungnahme CBH zu Formal Checks - 01.10.20242024-10-01Not public
Anlage CBH 54 - Überweisungsbeleg2024-10-01Not public
Formal-checks_Request-for-correction2024-09-30Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-09-19Not public
Berufung und Berufungsbegründung - CBH v. 19.09.20242024-09-19Not public
Anlage CBH 53 - Überweisungsbeleg2024-09-19Not public
Anlage CBH 52 - Tabelle Formal Checks2024-09-19Not public