UPC Analytics
DEEN
Übersicht · Eingereicht: 21. Mai 2024

UPC_CFI_239/2024

Machine for machining walls, particularly for walls made of wood or multilayer walls and the like

NichtigkeitHauptnichtigkeitsklageParis CDRevocationCase Closed
Parteien

Kläger

  • Name not displayed for GDPR reasons. Represented by Jasper WERHAHN
Vertreter: Jasper Carl Verhahn (Meissner Bolte)

Beklagte

  • Essetre Holding SpA
Vertreter: Giorgio Alessandro Karaghiosoff (Praxi Intellectual Property S.p.A.)
Richter

Französische Kammer — Einzelrichter anonymisiert.

  • Panel member (anonymized)
  • Panel member (anonymized)
  • Panel member (anonymized)
Patente
  • EP2875923
CPC-Codes: B27M1/08, B23Q3/04, B27M3/00, B27M3/0073, B27B27/10

Technologiebereich: Industrial Manufacturing · Woodworking Machinery

Ausgang
Patent geändertAufrechterhalten in geänderter Fassung
Eingereicht: 21. Mai 2024
Erste Entscheidung: 28. Juli 2025
Sprache: English

The Central Division Paris rejected the revocation action filed by an anonymous claimant against Essetre Holding spa in respect of EP 2 875 923 B1 (a machine for machining walls). The patent was maintained in amended form as submitted in the Principal Request on 8 August 2024. The Court interpreted 'a working surface' as meaning 'one working surface', applying the ordinary meaning in context of the description and drawings. The revocation action was dismissed as the defendant had submitted a patent limitation during proceedings. Costs were apportioned 70% to the claimant and 30% to the defendant. The case value for costs purposes was set at EUR 100,000.

Im UPC-Register öffnen
Ansprüche
Streitig1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, 10
Geändertall
Hinweise: Paris Central Division rejected revocation of EP2875923 (wall machining machine); claimant sought revocation of claims 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, 10 but patent was maintained in amended form as submitted in Principal Request.