UPClytics
Alle Fälle anzeigen

UPC CoA 360/2025

17. Apr. 2025·EP2201740 · HIGH SPEED PACKET PROCESSING IN A WIRELESS NETWORK

Verfahrensdetails
Status
Case Closed (Zurückgenommen)
Verfahrensart
Berufung
Kategorie
Hauptberufung
Parteien
Kläger
Vertreter
Beklagte
Vertreter
Division
Court of Appeal
Technologie
  • Electrical engineering
    Digital communication
Sprache
German
Erste Entscheidung
12. Aug. 2025
Letzte Entscheidung
17. Juli 2026
Im Vergleich
Wie lange das Gericht bis zu einer ersten Entscheidung braucht.
Median Tage bis zur ersten Entscheidung
Gesamt-UPC124
Richter Klaus GrabinskiGesperrt
Richter Peter BlokGesperrt
Richter Emmanuel GougéGesperrt
Richter Udo MatterGesperrt
Richter Klaus LoibnerGesperrt

Vor dem UPC: Lionra Technologies Ltd. (6 Verfahren)·Cisco Systems GmbH (7 Verfahren)

Entscheidungen
  • 2026-07-17

    Zusammenfassung: The Court of Appeal accepted Lionra's withdrawal of its appeal following an out-of-court settlement between the parties. The cross-appeal by Cisco was also deemed withdrawn. The appeal and cross-appeal proceedings were declared terminated. The request by Lionra for a 20% refund of court fees was rejected, as under the R. 370.9 RoP rules in force from 1 January 2026 a fee refund (of 50%) is only available if withdrawal occurs before the end of the written proceedings.

    Rechtsfragen anzeigen (4)
    • Withdrawal of appeal under R. 265.1 RoP following out-of-court settlement
    • Deemed withdrawal of cross-appeal upon withdrawal of main appeal
    • Refund of court fees under R. 370.9 RoP
    • Applicability of new court fee schedule (from 1 January 2026) to pending proceedings
  • 2025-08-12

    Zusammenfassung: Court of Appeal (12 August 2025) extended the deadline for Cisco to file its response to Lionra's appeal and any cross-appeal by two weeks (to 3 October 2025), finding a full month extension too long and one week too short given that Cisco had only recently obtained access to Lionra's unredacted appeal grounds (which contained confidential source code material).

    Rechtsfragen anzeigen (3)
    • Extension of time for appeal response (R. 9.3 RoP)
    • Confidentiality (R. 262A RoP)
    • Access to unredacted appeal grounds
DokumenttitelDatumÖffentlich
Verfahren abgeschlossen2026-07-20Nicht öffentlich
Veröffentlichung der Entscheidung2026-07-20Nicht öffentlich
Entscheidung2026-07-17Nicht öffentlich
Decision2026-07-17Öffentlich
Receipt2026-07-06Nicht öffentlich
Cover sheet2026-07-06Nicht öffentlich
Application Appellant2026-07-06Nicht öffentlich
Receipt2026-07-06Nicht öffentlich
Cover sheet2026-07-06Nicht öffentlich
Application Appellant2026-07-06Nicht öffentlich
Angenommene Argumente
Was das Gericht akzeptiert hat — nach Partei.
  • The new court fee refund rules under R. 370.9 RoP (in force from 1 January 2026) apply based on the date of the withdrawal request, not the date the appeal was filed; since the withdrawal was requested on 6 July 2026, the new rules apply

    BeklagterRechtsgrundlage: R. 370.9 RoP (version from 1 January 2026); general principle that individuals cannot rely on legislative stability
Zurückgewiesene Argumente
Was das Gericht nicht akzeptiert hat — und warum.
  • The old R. 370.9 RoP (prior to 1 January 2026) should apply to this appeal because it was already pending at that date, entitling Lionra to a 20% court fee refund upon withdrawal before oral proceedings

    KlägerRechtsgrundlage: R. 370.9 RoP (version prior to 1 January 2026); legal certainty / legitimate expectations