UPC Analytics
ENDE
Overview · Filed:

CC_65106/2024

Beet enclosure with a lockable sheet metal strip

Parent infringement case:UPC_CFI_338/2024

RevocationCounter Claim for RevocationMannheim LDCounterclaim for revocation
Parties

Claimants

  • bellissa HAAS GmbH
Reps: Lenz Bernecker

Respondents

  • Windhager GmbH
  • Johann Windhager
  • Stefan Windhager
Reps: Matthias Geitz
Judges
  • TochtermannPresiding judge
  • BöttcherJudge-rapporteur
  • KupeczLegally qualified judge
  • TilmannTechnically qualified judge
Patents
  • EP 2 223 589
CPC codes: H02S30/10, F24S2080/09, A01G9/28, Y02E10/47, Y02E10/50, F24S25/20

Technology area: Consumer Goods · Garden Products

Sector: Agriculture

Outcome
InfringedMaintained as granted
Filed:
First decided: Sep 12, 2025
Language:

Decision of the Mannheim Local Division finding infringement of EP 2 223 589 by Windhager GmbH (defendant 1) in Germany, Austria and Luxembourg, ordering an injunction, recall, removal from distribution channels, destruction of infringing products, information disclosure, and a declaration of damages liability. The revocation counterclaim was dismissed. Defendants bear costs. The decision establishes that supplying or offering all components of a patented product designed to be assembled without additional items at the point of use constitutes direct infringement under Art. 25(a) UPCA, and that selling even a single component of such a product when assembly is indicated also constitutes direct infringement.

Claims
At issueall
Infringedall
Notes: Mannheim LD found Windhager GmbH infringed EP2223589 in Germany, Austria and Luxembourg; revocation counterclaim dismissed; operative order describes infringing product by feature list rather than claim number.