UPClytics
ENDE
Sign inStart trial
View all cases

UPC CFI 240/2023

Jul 12, 2023·EP2145848 · False twist texturing machine

Action number: ACT 549550/2023

Follow
Case details
Status
Case Closed (Withdrawn)
Action
Infringement
Category
Main infringement action
Parties
Claimants
Representatives
  • Stefania Bergia
  • Giulio Sironi
Respondents
Representatives
  • Fabrizio Jacobacci
Division
Milan LD
Judges
Technology
  • Mechanical engineering
    Handling · Textile and paper machines
Language
Italian
First decided
Jul 21, 2023
Last decision
Dec 17, 2024
How this compares
The court's record for this kind of case, counted in first-instance rulings. A figure in brackets is the number of rulings a rate rests on.
Infringement foundMedian days to first decision
All UPC53% (62/117)124
Milan LDLockedLocked
Judge Pierluigi PerrottiLockedLocked
Judge Alima ZanaLockedLocked
Judge Carine GilletLockedLocked
Judge Michel AbelloLockedLocked

At the UPC: Oerlikon Textile GmbH & CO KG (13 cases)·Himson Engineering Private Limited (6 cases)

Start 14-day free trialAlready a user? Sign in
Related cases
All proceedings on this patent

This dispute contains 6 other proceedings

CC 596263/2023·UPC APP 562298/2023·UPC CFI 127/2023·UPC APP 28655/2024·UPC APP 33377/2025 and 1 more

4 other defendants litigating the same or a related patent

UPC CoA 12/2025·UPC CoA 8/2025·UPC CFI 761/2024·UPC CFI 241/2023

Start a free trial to see how each one ended.

More cases: Milan LD·2023

Decisions
  • 2024-12-17
    Infringement ActionPublic

    Summary: Procedural order (interim conference summary) of Milan Local Division in Oerlikon Textile v Himson Engineering (EP 2 145 848). The order summarises the procedural history (evidence preservation order, infringement and revocation counterclaim), the issues discussed at the interim conference (settlement proposals, claim construction, auxiliary requests) and confirms procedural arrangements for the oral hearing. Seven auxiliary requests remain before the court.

    Show the legal issues (3)
    • Interim conference procedure under R. 105 RoP
    • Auxiliary requests (patent amendment applications)
    • Admissibility of revocation grounds
  • 2024-11-25
    Public

    Summary: The Milan Local Division issued a case management order ahead of the oral hearing, addressing agenda items including settlement prospects, translation errors in the Italian validation of the patent, the counterclaim for revocation, auxiliary requests, and infringement evidence.

    Show the legal issues (4)
    • Case management interim conference
    • Counterclaim for revocation scope
    • Auxiliary requests
    • Infringement evidence (video)
  • 2024-09-17
    Infringement ActionPublic

    Summary: The Milan Local Division refused Oerlikon's request to admit an eighth auxiliary request to amend EP 2 145 848 B1, finding that AR8 did not constitute an effective response to the new prior art relied upon and that it introduced an inadmissible intermediate generalisation contrary to Art. 84 EPC.

    Show the legal issues (3)
    • admissibility of subsequent auxiliary request R.30.2 RoP
    • intermediate generalisation Art. 123(2) EPC
    • clarity Art. 84 EPC
  • 2024-07-23
    Public

    Summary: Procedural order of the Milan Local Division (in Italian) in Oerlikon Textile v Himson Engineering (EP 2 145 848) granting Oerlikon's application for a confidentiality order under R. 262A RoP over financial information provided in reply to a R. 158 RoP request. The court constituted a confidentiality club comprising only legal representatives of Himson (not the party itself), consistent with the financial sensitivity of the documents.

    Show the legal issues (3)
    • Confidentiality order under R. 262A RoP
    • Confidentiality club – access restricted to lawyers only, excluding party itself
    • Withdrawal of document from the file as alternative
  • 2023-09-27
    Infringement ActionPublic

    Summary: The Milan Local Division rejected a Rule 262.1(b) request for case file access filed by a lawyer claiming to represent Himson Engineering, holding that a lawyer who is party-affiliated (even without formal appearance) is not a 'third party' within the meaning of Rule 262.1(b) and cannot access the file before service is complete.

    Show the legal issues (3)
    • Rule 262.1(b) RoP access request
    • Third-party status for file access
    • Pre-service access
  • 2023-07-21
    Infringement ActionPublic

    Summary: The Milan Local Division ordered that the Statement of Claim be served on the defendants without transmitting copies of the approximately 2,000 pages of attached exhibits, with the claimant's prior consent.

    Show the legal issues (2)
    • Service without exhibits
    • Procedural efficiency
Documents
Document titleDatePublic
Case closed2026-02-20Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-09-09Not public
265 ROP2025-09-09Public
Receipt2025-07-22Not public
Receipt2025-07-22Not public
RINUNCIA AZIONE e CONTESTUALE ACCETTAZIONE della RINUNCIA AVVERSARIA AI SENSI DELLA RULE 265 ROP2025-07-22Not public
Withdrawal ex Rule 265 RoP per Oerlikon PDFA2025-07-22Not public
Receipt2025-06-20Not public
doc. 11_Ricevuta pagamento Court Fee2025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.8_Fattura servizio interpretariato dott.ssa Ventola2025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.1_Invoice n. 20250300483 - 14 Aprile 20252025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.5_ Invoice Ing. Leihkauf - Maggio 20252025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.7_ Invoice Ing. Leihkauf - Giugno 20252025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.2_ Invoice Ing. Leihkauf - Marzo 20252025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.6_Invoice n. 20250300825 - 17 Giugno 20252025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.4_Invoice n. 20250300724 - 05 Giugno 20252025-06-19Not public
doc. 10.3_Invoice n. 20250300673 - 15 Maggio 20252025-06-19Not public
Nota Spese 19.06.252025-06-19Not public
Receipt2025-06-16Not public
Doc. 58 Auxiliary Request 5 plus 7 IT marked up and clean copy2025-06-16Not public
Nota spese Oerlikon e nota di deposito PDFA2025-06-16Not public
Doc. 59 Auxiliary Request 6 plus 7 DE marked up and clean copy2025-06-16Not public
Doc. 55 Auxiliary Request 4 plus 7 DE marked up and clean copy2025-06-16Not public
Doc. 57 Auxiliary Request 5 plus 7 DE marked up and clean copy2025-06-16Not public
Doc. 60 Auxiliary Request 6 plus 7 IT marked up and clean copy2025-06-16Not public
Doc. 56 Auxiliary Request 4 plus 7 IT marked up and clean copy2025-06-16Not public
Receipt2025-03-31Not public
Riassunto autorizzato nell interesse di Oerlikon signed2025-03-31Not public
Receipt2025-03-31Not public
9.7 Fattura ing. Leikhauf - Febbraio 20252025-03-31Not public
9.3 Fattura n. 20250300070 _ 15 gennaio 20252025-03-31Not public
9.5 Fattura ing. Leikhauf - Novembre 20242025-03-31Not public
9.1 Fattura n. 20240301506 _ 14 novembre 20242025-03-31Not public
9.4 Fattura n. 20250300337 _ 13 marzo 20252025-03-31Not public
9.6 Fattura ing. Leikhauf - Dicembre 20242025-03-31Not public
9 Elenco fattture per attivita rese fino a febbraio 20252025-03-31Not public
9.2 Fattura n. 20240301625 _ 12 dicembre 20242025-03-31Not public
Nota autorizzata 31.03.252025-03-31Not public
Nota di deposito per Oerlikon2025-02-27Not public
Nota autorizzata 27.02.252025-02-27Not public
final order interim conference2024-12-17Public
549550-23_IC_MIL-LOC_UPC202412060230PM2024-12-13Not public
549550-23_IC_MIL-LOC_UPC202412060230PM2024-12-13Not public
Fix-Interim-Conference-Date2024-12-12Not public
final order rule 9 order 25 novembre 20242024-11-27Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-11-27Not public
order 27 novembre 2024 IC2024-11-27Public
Receipt2024-11-25Not public
Istanza differimento Interim Conference2024-11-25Not public
All._A_Decreto_fissazione_udienza_orale_per_il_6.12.2024_Trib_Torino2024-11-25Not public
rule 9 interim conference 25 novembre 20242024-11-25Public
rule 9 interim conference 25 novembre 20242024-11-25Not public
Doc. 51 - Fattura S+S n. 8 (IT012402192)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 48 - Fattura S+S n. 5 (IT012401040)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 50 - Fattura S+S n. 7 (IT012401772)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 44 - Ricevuta pagamento Court Fee2024-11-18Not public
Oerlikon - Note autorizzate ex art. 103 RoP signed2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 47 - Fattura S+S n. 4 (IT012400713)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 41 - EP2145848 EPO examination proceedings (ENG translation)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 46 - Fattura S+S n. 3 (IT012400749)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 43 - Fattura Ing. Marietti2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 45 - Fattura S+S n. 2 (IT012400220)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 49 - Fattura S+S n. 6 (IT012401383)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 42 - Fattura S+S n. 1 (IT012302052)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 52 - Fattura S_S n. 9 (IT012402459)2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 8_Fatture Himson2024-11-18Not public
Doc. 5V4 bis_Traduzione italiana lettera di replica e modifica del 18.08.20102024-11-18Not public
Doc. 5D1 bis_Traduzione italiana D1 DE1910342A12024-11-18Not public
Doc. 5D5 bis_Traduzione italiana WO2007036242A12024-11-18Not public
Doc. 5D6 bis_Traduzione italiana WO03002793A12024-11-18Not public
Doc. 6D8 bis_Traduzione italiana DE10123042A12024-11-18Not public
Memoria autorizzata ai sensi della Rule 103ROP_18.11.242024-11-18Not public
Doc. 5V2 bis_Traduzione italiana EP2145848A12024-11-18Not public
fine written procedure2024-10-07Public
interimConferenceDecision2024-10-07Not public
writtenProcedureClosure2024-10-07Not public
IC OH 24 luglio 20242024-07-24Public
Oerlikon Reply pursuant to RoP 2642024-07-16Not public
Oerlikon Comments pursuant to Rule 264 RoP2024-07-11Not public
Comments pursuant to RoP264_11 07 20242024-07-11Not public
nuove date udienze2024-07-04Not public
Receipt2024-06-14Not public
IMG_19452024-06-14Not public
IMG_19402024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1532282024-06-14Not public
UPC Local Division MILANO 498862_2023 Photos HIMSON 14Jun232024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1524522024-06-14Not public
IMG_19432024-06-14Not public
UPC Milano Proc_498862_2023 Photos HIMSON 2of32024-06-14Not public
498862_2023_UPC Milano Relazione tecnica HIMSON 14Giu232024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1531432024-06-14Not public
498862_2023_UPC Milano - Appointment Approval2024-06-14Not public
UPC Milano Proc_498862_2023 Photos HIMSON 1of32024-06-14Not public
UPC Local Division MILANO 498862_2023 Photos HIMSON 14Jun23 Red2024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1532322024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1531402024-06-14Not public
IMG_19442024-06-14Not public
IMG_19412024-06-14Not public
498862_2023_UPC Milano Appointment Approval SIGNED2024-06-14Not public
IMG_19422024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1525052024-06-14Not public
Oerlikon Nota di deposito ai sensi della Rule 9 RoP SIGNED2024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1532342024-06-14Not public
498862_2023_UPC Milano Relazione tecnica HIMSON SIGNED2024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1531212024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1531312024-06-14Not public
UPC Milano Proc_498862_2023 Photos HIMSON 3of32024-06-14Not public
IMG_20230614_1524552024-06-14Not public
IMG_19392024-06-14Not public
rule 9 accesso report expert 4 giugno 20242024-06-04Public
rule 9 ROP 23 maggio 20242024-05-23Public
acquisizione prove raccolte ante causam2024-05-06Public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-04-19Not public
Doc.6D8_DE10123042A12024-04-19Not public
Rejoinder to the reply to the statement of defence2024-04-19Not public
Doc.6D9_US6990795B22024-04-19Not public
Doc.6_parere tecnico integrativo Steffen Leihkauf2024-04-19Not public
Reply pursuant to RoP 264 and 3372024-04-08Not public
Reply pursuant to RoP264_08.04.24-signed.pdf2024-04-08Not public
Comments pursuant to Artt. 264 and 337 RoP2024-04-02Not public
Commenti autorizzati 264 ROP2024-04-02Not public
ROP 3362024-03-15Not public
articolo 9 ROP2024-02-29Public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-02-20Not public
Traduzione italiana Parere Laus2024-02-20Not public
Reply to the Statement of Defence pursuant to Rule 29 lett. a) RoP2024-02-20Not public
Articolo Himson setting new standars2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 1 [IT]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 6 [DE]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 7 [IT]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 5 [DE]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 7 [DE]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 3 [DE]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 4 [DE]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 5 [IT]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 2 [IT]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 2 [DE]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 3 [IT]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 1 [DE]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 4 [IT]2024-02-20Not public
Auxiliary Request 6 [IT]2024-02-20Not public
Parere tecnico Mr Florian Laus2024-02-20Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-02-05Not public
ROP 332024-02-05Not public
Reply pursuant to RoP2642024-02-02Not public
Hearing-Dates2024-01-31Not public
rule 28 RoP confirmation set dates2024-01-31Not public
Reply pursuant to RoP2642024-01-29Not public
Comments pursuant to RoP 264 regarding the appointment of a Technically Qualified Judge2024-01-25Not public
Comments pursuant to RoP 28 and 2642024-01-19Not public
art. 33 ROP preliminary order TQJ signed2024-01-15Not public
IC OH case n .549550 2023 signed2024-01-11Not public
Hearing-Dates2024-01-11Not public
Receipt2023-12-22Not public
Statement of Defence Himson_final-signed2023-12-21Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-12-21Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2023-12-21Not public
Statement of Defence Himson_final-signed2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5D4_US2004098964A2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5V1_EP2145848B12023-12-21Not public
Segmento 002 di Doc. 2_Service of the order for preservation and Ms. Zana s order2023-12-21Not public
Segmento 001 di Doc. 2_Service of the order for preservation and Ms. Zana s order2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5C3_brochure HSS-AX4-11G2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5D3_JP2005068573A2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5D1_DE1910342A12023-12-21Not public
Doc. 1_Statement of Claim_Infringment Action Act 549550_20232023-12-21Not public
Doc.5D5_WO2007036242A12023-12-21Not public
Doc.5D2_GB1401433A2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5V3_convalida italiana IT5020119020077132023-12-21Not public
Doc.5V2_EP2145848A12023-12-21Not public
Doc.5C2_brochure HSS-AX-11G-TS2023-12-21Not public
Doc. 4_screenshots himson2023-12-21Not public
Doc. 5_Parere Tecnico Ing. Leikhauf2023-12-21Not public
Segmento 003 di Doc. 2_Service of the order for preservation and Ms. Zana s order2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5.D7_EP0903431A22023-12-21Not public
Doc.5C4_brochure HSS-AX4-N2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5D6_WO03002793A12023-12-21Not public
Doc. 3_Codice accesso procedimento urgenza2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5V4_lettera di replica e modifica del 18.08.20102023-12-21Not public
Doc.5D3bis_Traduzione inglese di JP2005068573A2023-12-21Not public
Doc.5C1_brochure HSS-AX-11G-AT2023-12-21Not public
Formal-checks_Request-for-correction2023-12-21Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5C2_brochure HSS-AX-11G-TS2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5D6_WO03002793A12023-12-20Not public
Doc.5D3_JP2005068573A2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5V1_EP2145848B12023-12-20Not public
Doc.5C4_brochure HSS-AX4-N2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5.D7_EP0903431A22023-12-20Not public
Doc. 4_screenshots himson2023-12-20Not public
Segmento 001 di Doc. 2_Service of the order for preservation and Ms. Zana s order2023-12-20Not public
Segmento 002 di Doc. 2_Service of the order for preservation and Ms. Zana s order2023-12-20Not public
Doc. 3_Codice accesso procedimento urgenza2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5D4_US2004098964A2023-12-20Not public
Segmento 003 di Doc. 2_Service of the order for preservation and Ms. Zana s order2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5C3_brochure HSS-AX4-11G2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5V3_convalida italiana IT5020119020077132023-12-20Not public
Doc.5D2_GB1401433A2023-12-20Not public
Statement of Defence and Counterclaim for revocation2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5V2_EP2145848A12023-12-20Not public
Doc. 5_Parere Tecnico Ing. Leikhauf2023-12-20Not public
Doc. 1_Statement of Claim_Infringment Action Act 549550_20232023-12-20Not public
Doc.5V4_lettera di replica e modifica del 18.08.20102023-12-20Not public
Doc.5D1_DE1910342A12023-12-20Not public
Doc.5D5_WO2007036242A12023-12-20Not public
Doc.5D3bis_Traduzione inglese di JP2005068573A2023-12-20Not public
Doc.5C1_brochure HSS-AX-11G-AT2023-12-20Not public
Notification Of Service2023-12-20Not public
service receipt by Himson2023-12-20Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2023-12-19Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2023-09-26Not public
articolo 9 ROP2023-07-21Not public
articolo 9 ROP2023-07-20Not public
articolo 9 ROP2023-07-20Not public
epoUploadDocumentsWorkflow2023-07-20Not public
Letter for Service2023-07-20Not public
Panel-Appointment2023-07-20Not public
Document from EPO2023-07-19Not public
statementOfClaim2023-07-17Not public
Receipt2023-07-17Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2023-07-14Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 7.12023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 12.22023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 13.12023-07-12Not public
Statement of claim2023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 11.12023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 22023-07-12Not public
Statement of claim2023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 11.22023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 13.22023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 32023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 82023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 12.12023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 42023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 92023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 52023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 62023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 7.22023-07-12Not public
Ricorso Oerlikon 60 Accordo TUB e 192 ss. ROP2023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 102023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 7.22023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 142023-07-12Not public
Exhibit 3 bis2023-07-12Not public