UPClytics
EnglishDeutsch
Sign inSign up
View all cases

UPC CFI 252/2023

Jul 27, 2023·EP2794928: COMPOSITIONS AND METHODS FOR ANALYTE DETECTION

Case details
Status
Case Closed
Action
Revocation
Category
Main Revocation Action
Parties
Claimants
Reps: Axel Berger
Respondents
Reps: Daniela Kinkeldey
Division
Munich CD
Judges
Technology
Biotech · Diagnostics · Biotechnology
Language
English
First decided
Oct 4, 2023
Last decision
Oct 30, 2023
Decisions
  • 2023-10-30
    Revocation Action

    The Munich Central Division ordered Harvard College (claimant/defendant in revocation action) to provide security for legal costs under Article 69(4) UPCA and Rule 158 RoP, finding legitimate concern about enforcement of a potential cost order against NanoString Technologies Europe (a UK-based entity) in light of a preliminary injunction already imposed.

    Legal issues:Security for legal costs (Art. 69(4) UPCA, Rule 158 RoP)Enforcement in UKProportionalityArticle 47 EU Charter
  • 2023-10-04
    Revocation Action

    The Munich Central Division ordered that a preliminary objection based on Articles 29 and 30 Brussels Ibis Regulation (lis pendens / related actions) be dealt with in the main proceedings rather than separately, for reasons of procedural economy and efficiency under Rule 20.2 RoP.

    Legal issues:Preliminary objection (Rule 48 RoP)Jurisdiction (Arts. 29-30 Brussels Ibis)Lis pendensRule 20.2 RoP
Documents
Document titleDatePublic
Procedural Order2025-01-03Not public
Order re Release of Security2024-12-17Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2024-12-17Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-12-17Not public
final order application to release security2024-12-17Public
final order application to release security2024-12-17Not public
Template-Order2024-12-17Not public
Reply2024-12-09Not public
241125 NanoString - Response to order re security2024-11-25Not public
preliminary order2024-11-18Not public
preliminary order2024-11-18Not public
Comments re cost security - 2024-10-25_signed2024-10-25Not public
preliminary order2024-10-18Not public
Receipt2024-10-18Not public
BSec32024-10-17Not public
241017 NanoString - Request to release security2024-10-17Not public
BSec12024-10-17Not public
BSec22024-10-17Not public
BSec42024-10-17Not public
Decision anonymised2024-10-17Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2024-10-17Not public
DecisionOutcome2024-10-17Not public
decision revocation action 252/20232024-10-17Public
decision revocation action 252/20232024-10-17Not public
Recording of Oral Hearing - Reference2024-09-25Not public
Recording of Oral Hearing - Reference2024-09-25Not public
Receipt2024-09-18Not public
Rule 9 RoP application2024-09-17Not public
Receipt2024-09-05Not public
Receipt2024-09-05Not public
Application for Protection of Confidentiality_R262A_Harvard2024-09-04Not public
Exhibit BP29 - Harvard - Confidential2024-09-04Not public
Submission for costs incurred_Harvard2024-09-04Not public
Submission of Harvard re attendees in oral hearing2024-09-04Not public
Final Order2024-09-04Not public
Receipt2024-09-03Not public
240903 NanoString Attendees oral hearing2024-09-03Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-08-20Not public
RoP 9 order2024-08-20Not public
RoP 9 order2024-08-20Public
Template-Order2024-08-20Not public
RoP 9 order2024-08-20Not public
240816 comments pursuant to RoP2642024-08-16Not public
Opportunity to comment2024-08-14Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-08-14Not public
Translation of Exhibits2024-08-14Public
Receipt2024-08-13Not public
Exhibit BP27 - Harvard - EN2024-08-13Not public
Request of Harvard for procedural order_signed - EN2024-08-13Not public
Exhibit BP28 - Harvard - DE2024-08-13Not public
Receipt2024-08-12Not public
240812 submission forwarding DE nullity decision2024-08-12Not public
D602024-08-12Not public
interimProcedureClosure2024-07-25Not public
summons2024-07-25Not public
summons oral hearing2024-07-25Public
Hearing-Dates2024-07-25Not public
RoP 9 Order2024-07-25Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-07-25Not public
RoP 9 order2024-07-25Public
RoP 9 order2024-07-25Not public
RoP 9 order2024-07-25Not public
240724 inadmissibility of further submission of patentee2024-07-24Not public
preliminary order re further submission2024-07-23Not public
Receipt2024-07-23Not public
Brief - Harvard 2024-07-22_signed2024-07-22Not public
Exhibit BP 252024-07-22Not public
Exhibit BP 262024-07-22Not public
Receipt2024-05-16Not public
D582024-05-16Not public
D592024-05-16Not public
240516 submission RE closing2024-05-16Not public
240516 submission RE closing2024-05-16Not public
D582024-05-16Not public
D592024-05-16Not public
Receipt2024-04-26Not public
240426 NanoString Submission2024-04-26Not public
D572024-04-26Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-04-02Not public
order re postponement oral hearing2024-04-02Public
Brief Harvard (signed) - 2024-03-202024-03-20Not public
240320 submission on invalidity of AR22024-03-20Not public
preliminary order2024-03-15Not public
Receipt2024-03-15Not public
240315 submission response R 103/105.5 RoP2024-03-15Not public
D562024-03-15Not public
Receipt2024-03-08Not public
Preliminary Order2024-03-08Not public
Response to US043 attacks Harvard signed - 2024-03-072024-03-07Not public
240307 NanoString Response to Defendant2024-03-07Not public
preliminary order subsequent application to amend2024-03-04Not public
Receipt2024-03-04Not public
Exhibit BP23a - Harvard - EN2024-03-01Not public
Exhibit BP24a - Harvard - EN_signed2024-03-01Not public
Exhibit BP23 - Harvard - DE2024-03-01Not public
Subsequent Application to amend the patent - 2024-03-01_signed2024-03-01Not public
Exhibit BP24 - Harvard - EN_signed2024-03-01Not public
Exhibit BP24a - Harvard - EN_signed2024-03-01Not public
Exhibit BP24 - Harvard - EN_signed2024-03-01Not public
Subsequent Application to amend the patent - 2024-03-01_signed2024-03-01Not public
Exhibit BP23 - Harvard - DE2024-03-01Not public
Exhibit BP23a - Harvard - EN2024-03-01Not public
final order 103/105.5 RoP2024-02-02Public
final order 103/105.5 RoP2024-02-02Not public
Template-Order2024-02-02Not public
interim conference reference2024-02-02Not public
interim conference reference2024-02-02Not public
Fix-Interim-Conference-Date2024-02-02Not public
final RoP103-105 order after interim conference2024-01-31Not public
final RoP103-105 order after interim conference2024-01-31Public
final order IC2024-01-31Not public
Template-Order2024-01-31Not public
Template-Order2024-01-31Not public
interimConferenceDecision2024-01-24Not public
writtenProcedureClosure2024-01-24Not public
intended closure written proceedings and interim conference invitation2024-01-16Not public
rejoinAmendPatentDefence2024-01-12Not public
Rejoinder to the Reply to the Defense to an application to amend the Patent2024-01-12Not public
D552024-01-12Not public
D55A2024-01-12Not public
replyAmendPatentDefence2023-12-27Not public
Reply to the Defence to the Application to amend the Patent Harvard (signed)2023-12-27Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-12-27Not public
Rejoinder to the Reply to the Defence to Revocation Harvard (signed)2023-12-27Not public
Outcome of the Order2023-12-12Not public
confirmation order2023-12-12Not public
Receipt2023-12-05Not public
Confirmation of payment2023-12-05Not public
amendPatentDefence2023-11-27Not public
D172023-11-27Not public
D462023-11-27Not public
D432023-11-27Not public
D442023-11-27Not public
D232023-11-27Not public
D062023-11-27Not public
D332023-11-27Not public
D212023-11-27Not public
D512023-11-27Not public
D182023-11-27Not public
D372023-11-27Not public
D452023-11-27Not public
D362023-11-27Not public
D522023-11-27Not public
D052023-11-27Not public
D102023-11-27Not public
D042023-11-27Not public
D142023-11-27Not public
D29A2023-11-27Not public
D252023-11-27Not public
D382023-11-27Not public
D322023-11-27Not public
D352023-11-27Not public
D26A2023-11-27Not public
D112023-11-27Not public
D012023-11-27Not public
D202023-11-27Not public
D312023-11-27Not public
D292023-11-27Not public
D282023-11-27Not public
D162023-11-27Not public
D032023-11-27Not public
D122023-11-27Not public
D132023-11-27Not public
D422023-11-27Not public
D152023-11-27Not public
D472023-11-27Not public
D412023-11-27Not public
D392023-11-27Not public
D492023-11-27Not public
D192023-11-27Not public
D402023-11-27Not public
D222023-11-27Not public
D262023-11-27Not public
D092023-11-27Not public
D072023-11-27Not public
D022023-11-27Not public
D342023-11-27Not public
D542023-11-27Not public
EP928 response to patentee2023-11-27Not public
D27A2023-11-27Not public
D242023-11-27Not public
D272023-11-27Not public
D302023-11-27Not public
D082023-11-27Not public
D532023-11-27Not public
D28A2023-11-27Not public
D502023-11-27Not public
D482023-11-27Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-11-27Not public
D462023-11-27Not public
EP928 response to patentee2023-11-27Not public
D472023-11-27Not public
D502023-11-27Not public
D532023-11-27Not public
D492023-11-27Not public
D482023-11-27Not public
D542023-11-27Not public
D522023-11-27Not public
D512023-11-27Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-11-06Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2023-11-06Not public
Outcome of the Order2023-11-03Not public
order closing workflow2023-11-03Not public
Official Date2023-11-03Not public
Final order RoP 28 dd 031120232023-11-03Not public
NanoString - Response to preliminary order RoP 28 of 2 Nov 2023 (timing)2023-11-03Not public
Exhibit BP14a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP9 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP18a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP16a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP13 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP13a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP10 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit Application to amend patent - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP18 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP7a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP17a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP16 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP7 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP15a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP11 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP14 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP12 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP8 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP17 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Application to amend patent Harvard (signed) - 2023-11-022023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP15 - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
Exhibit BP12a - Harvard - EN2023-11-02Not public
RoP28 further preliminary order dated 2 November 20232023-11-02Not public
Template-Order2023-11-02Not public
Bundle of Exhibits BP 22 - Harvard - DE2023-10-31Not public
Response to Preliminary order Harvard (signed) - 2023-10-312023-10-31Not public
Response to preliminary order RoP 28 dated 271020232023-10-31Not public
Final order security request RoP 158.12023-10-30Not public
preliminary order RoP 28 dated 271020232023-10-27Not public
RoP 28 preliminary order 271020232023-10-27Not public
Receipt2023-10-26Not public
Application R 9 RoP further comments on timing2023-10-26Not public
Bundle of exhibits BP21 - Harvard - DE2023-10-20Not public
Response of Harvard to Preliminary Order RoP 28 (signed) - 2023-10-202023-10-20Not public
Exhibit BP20 - Harvard - DE2023-10-20Not public
Comments on timing proposed by the central division2023-10-19Not public
Response to patentee submission re security for legal costs2023-10-16Not public
preliminary order RoP 28 dated 161020232023-10-16Not public
Provisional Date2023-10-16Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2023-10-05Not public
Exhibit BP19 - Harvard - EN2023-10-04Not public
Response to Preliminary order Harvard (signed) - 2023-10-042023-10-04Not public
Exhibit BP4a - Harvard - EN2023-10-04Not public
Preliminary_Objection_DecisionOutcome2023-10-04Not public
Order informing the parties in accordance with Rule 20.2 RoP2023-10-04Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP14a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP16 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP14 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP18a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP18 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP15 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP6 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP13a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP15a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP7a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP16a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP7 Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP5 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP12 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Defence to revocation Harvard signed - 2023-09-282023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP4 - Harvard - DE2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP9 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP11 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP8 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP12a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP13 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP17a - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP10 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Exhibit BP17 - Harvard - EN2023-09-28Not public
Response to Defendant and to preliminary opinion2023-09-28Not public
Response of Harvard to preliminary order - 2023-09-222023-09-22Not public
Preliminary order Rule 9 RoP re security request2023-09-20Not public
Template-Order2023-09-20Not public
Preliminary Order 15 September2023-09-15Not public
commentPreliminaryObjection2023-09-11Not public
Comment on preliminary objection2023-09-11Not public
preliminaryObjection2023-08-29Not public
Exhibit_BP032023-08-28Not public
Exhibit_BP022023-08-28Not public
Exhibit_BP012023-08-28Not public
Preliminary objection AND Security for legal costs2023-08-28Not public
epoUploadDocumentsWorkflow2023-08-04Not public
Document from EPO2023-08-01Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2023-07-28Not public
Notification Of Service2023-07-28Not public
Panel-Appointment2023-07-27Not public
statementOfRevocation2023-07-27Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-07-27Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2023-07-27Not public
D312023-07-27Not public
D022023-07-27Not public
D282023-07-27Not public
D112023-07-27Not public
D162023-07-27Not public
D442023-07-27Not public
D172023-07-27Not public
Proof of Payment2023-07-27Not public
D222023-07-27Not public
D042023-07-27Not public
Revocation action2023-07-27Not public
D352023-07-27Not public
D132023-07-27Not public
D192023-07-27Not public
D412023-07-27Not public
D052023-07-27Not public
D242023-07-27Not public
D432023-07-27Not public
D202023-07-27Not public
D062023-07-27Not public
D402023-07-27Not public
D392023-07-27Not public
D152023-07-27Not public
D292023-07-27Not public
D232023-07-27Not public
D182023-07-27Not public
D122023-07-27Not public
D252023-07-27Not public
D422023-07-27Not public
D452023-07-27Not public
D262023-07-27Not public
D29A2023-07-27Not public
D082023-07-27Not public
D072023-07-27Not public
D142023-07-27Not public
D382023-07-27Not public
D012023-07-27Not public
D302023-07-27Not public
D28A2023-07-27Not public
D272023-07-27Not public
D322023-07-27Not public
D092023-07-27Not public
D032023-07-27Not public
D27A2023-07-27Not public
D362023-07-27Not public
D26A2023-07-27Not public
D102023-07-27Not public
D212023-07-27Not public
D332023-07-27Not public
D372023-07-27Not public
D342023-07-27Not public
D012023-07-27Not public