UPClytics
EnglishDeutsch
Sign inSign up
View all cases

UPC CFI 487/2023

Dec 27, 2023·EP2645714 +1 more: Video decoding device, video decoding method, and program

Case details
Status
Case Closed
Action
Infringement
Category
Main Infringement Action
Parties
Claimants
Reps: Müller (Bardehle Pagenberg); Henke (Bardehle Pagenberg)
Division
Munich LD
Judges
Technology
Telecoms · Video Codecs · Telecommunications
Language
English
Decisions
  • 2025-01-17
    SettledApplication Rop 265

    The Munich Local Division confirmed the withdrawal of NEC Corporation's patent infringement action against TCL entities concerning EP 2 645 714. The parties had reached a contractual agreement before closure of the written procedure. The court granted the withdrawal and ordered 60% reimbursement of court fees to the claimant. Each party bears its own costs; no cost decision was issued.

    Legal issues:Withdrawal of action (R. 265 RoP)Reimbursement of court fees (R. 370 RoP)60% fee reimbursement for pre-closure withdrawal
Documents
Document titleDatePublic
action.phaseChange.caseClose2025-10-30Not public
Cover sheet2025-10-20Not public
Other document2025-10-20Not public
Receipt2025-10-20Not public
Cover sheet2025-10-15Not public
Further pleadings2025-10-15Not public
Receipt2025-10-15Not public
action.communication.general2025-10-08Not public
Cover sheet2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Exhibit2025-09-29Not public
Application2025-09-29Not public
Application2025-09-29Not public
Receipt2025-09-29Not public
Cover sheet2025-09-29Not public
Other document2025-09-29Not public
Receipt2025-09-29Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-09-17Not public
Workflow geschlossen2025-09-17Public
2025-09-16_Brief_of_NEC_-_withdrawal_request_leave_to_appeal_A169308VLU22 - signed.pdf2025-09-16Not public
2025-09-11 Order - invitation to comment2025-09-11Not public
Receipt2025-09-11Not public
2025-09-10_Brief_of_NEC_-_request_leave_to_appeal_A169308VLU22 - signed2025-09-10Not public
Receipt2025-08-14Not public
Receipt2025-08-13Not public
2025-08-12_Brief_of_NEC_-_Rule-262.2__A169308VLU22 - signed.pdf2025-08-13Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03h - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail an TCL Com)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03d - NEC (Lowenstein Sandler)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03f - NEC (HEVC Advance - E-Mail 2102018)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03i - NEC (Standard-Lizenzvertrag)_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Statement of claim - NEC_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Statement of claim - NEC dd December 22 2023_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03h - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail an TCL Com)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03j - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail Claimcharts)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03g - NEC (Access Advance - E-Mail 26102020)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03e - NEC (TCL - E-Mail 2372018)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03a - NEC (HEVC Advance 2752016 EN)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03b - NEC (HEVC Advance 22092016 EN)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03f - NEC (HEVC Advance - E-Mail 2102018)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03j - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail Claimcharts)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03b - NEC (HEVC Advance 22092016 EN)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 07 - NEC (Memo PRC Law KWM)_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 07 - NEC (Memo PRC Law KWM)_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03i - NEC (Standard-Lizenzvertrag)_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03c - NEC (HEVC Advance 25092017 EN)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03e - NEC (TCL - E-Mail 2372018)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03a - NEC (HEVC Advance 2752016 EN)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03d - NEC (Lowenstein Sandler)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03g - NEC (Access Advance - E-Mail 26102020)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
2025-08-12_Brief_of_NEC_-_Rule-9__A169308VLU22 - signed.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Statement of claim - NEC_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03c - NEC (HEVC Advance 25092017 EN)_confidential.PDF2025-08-12Not public
A169308VLU22 Statement of claim - NEC dd December 22 2023_confidential.pdf2025-08-12Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2025-07-31Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-07-31Not public
FVA2025-07-31Public
Receipt2025-07-31Not public
2025-07-31 Brief of NEC - request of time extension A169308VLU22_signed.pdf2025-07-31Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2025-01-27Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-01-27Not public
Withdrawal and Reimbursement2025-01-27Public
Headnote-and-Keywords2025-01-17Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-01-17Not public
Rücknahme Klage und Gebührenerstattung2025-01-17Public
Invitation to comment2025-01-14Not public
Invitation to comment2025-01-14Not public
Receipt2025-01-14Not public
Noerr_Withdrawal_Counterclaim_595922_2023_CC_40351_20242025-01-14Not public
Receipt2025-01-14Not public
2025-01-14 Withdrawal of complaint - NEC_A169308VLU22 - signed2025-01-14Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-10-31Not public
Stay of proceedings2024-10-31Public
Receipt2024-10-31Not public
2024-10-29 Consent of TCL regarding Stay of proceeding.pdf2024-10-30Not public
2024-10-30 Stay of proceedings - Request of NEC_A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-10-30Not public
2024-10-25 Order - invitation to comment2024-10-25Not public
A169308VLU22_Exhibit_BP-18_Advance_AAL_redacted.pdf2024-10-25Not public
2024-10-25 Brief of NEC re statement in response to application for panel review_A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-10-25Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-10-18Not public
Closing of the workflow2024-10-18Public
Opportunity to comment2024-10-18Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-10-18Not public
Receipt2024-10-17Not public
Noerr_Application_Panel_Review_AA_Intervention_ACT_595922_2023_App_56525_20242024-10-16Not public
Nachweis_Zahlung_Gerichtsgebuehr_595922_2023_App_56525_20242024-10-16Not public
2024-10-15_Exhibit_BP-17_Statement_of_claim_-_NEC_with_corrected_Def._7_A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-10-16Not public
2024-10-15_Brief_of_NEC_Application_to_amend_the_pleading_A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-10-16Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-10-14Not public
Extension time limit2024-10-14Public
Outcome of the Order2024-10-14Not public
Extension time limit2024-10-14Public
Receipt2024-10-14Not public
Receipt2024-10-14Not public
Noerr Request Time Extension2024-10-14Not public
Adress for Service2024-10-11Public
2024-10-11 Time extension - Request of NEC A169308VLU22 - signed.pdf2024-10-11Not public
Headnote-and-Keyword-Translated2024-10-10Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2024-10-03Not public
Admission intervention2024-10-03Not public
Admission intervention2024-10-03Public
Headnote-and-Keywords2024-10-02Not public
2024-10-02 - Order - Admission of intervention2024-10-02Not public
2024-10-02 - Order - Admission of intervention2024-10-02Public
Outcome of the Order2024-09-30Not public
Amendment CO2024-09-30Public
Noerr_Statement_amendment_order_595922_2023_App_53330_20242024-09-27Not public
Noerr_Statement_amendment_order_595922_2023_App_53330_20242024-09-27Not public
Noerr_Statement_amendment_order_595922_2023_App_53330_20242024-09-27Not public
Noerr_Statement_amendment_order_595922_2023_App_53330_20242024-09-27Not public
Opportunity to comment2024-09-26Not public
Receipt2024-09-26Not public
2024-09-25 Brief of NEC - request to amend confidentiality order R9 A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-09-25Not public
Order - 20 2 - PO - Dealing in the main proceedings2024-09-23Public
Outcome of the Order2024-09-23Not public
Closing of the workflow2024-09-23Public
Order - 262 A - Defendant 22024-09-23Not public
Order - 262 A - Defendant 22024-09-23Public
commentPreliminaryObjection2024-09-17Not public
2024-09-17_Brief of NEC - re PO R19_A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-09-17Not public
Noerr_Statement_confidentiality_order_Def_2_595922_2023_App_46109_20242024-09-12Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-09-10Not public
Fristverlängerung2024-09-10Public
2024-09-09_Brief_of_NEC_and_Advance_-__Statement_On_Intervention_A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-09-09Not public
2024-09-03_Brief of NEC - Statement deadline harmonization_A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-09-03Not public
Noerr_Statement_time_periods_595922_2023_App_48617_20242024-09-03Not public
preliminaryObjection2024-09-03Not public
Annex D 262024-09-02Not public
Annex D 222024-09-02Not public
Annex D 272024-09-02Not public
Annex D 242024-09-02Not public
Annex D 192024-09-02Not public
Annex D 082024-09-02Not public
Annex D 232024-09-02Not public
Annex D 092024-09-02Not public
Annex D 102024-09-02Not public
Annex D 212024-09-02Not public
Annex D 282024-09-02Not public
Annex D 012024-09-02Not public
Annex D 202024-09-02Not public
Annex D 072024-09-02Not public
Annex D 252024-09-02Not public
20240902_Preliminary_Objections_595922_2023_Defendant_5_App_49696_20242024-09-02Not public
2024-09-02 Order Invitation to comment2024-09-02Not public
2024-08-31 Invitation to comment on Defendants' objections to appl to intervene2024-08-31Not public
Notification Of Service2024-08-29Not public
Proof of service2024-08-29Not public
2024-08-28 Statement on R. 262A confidentiality request of Defendant 2 A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-08-28Not public
2024-08-27 Prel Order - invitation to comment time limit regime2024-08-27Not public
20240827_Noerr_Statement_Intervention_AA_595922_2023_ORD_46842_20242024-08-27Not public
Noerr_Statement_Intervention_AA_595922_2023_ORD_46842_20242024-08-27Not public
Annex D 362024-08-27Not public
Annex D 382024-08-27Not public
Annex D 372024-08-27Not public
Receipt2024-08-27Not public
2024-08-26 Brief of NEC re statement of admissibility of application to intervene A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-08-26Not public
Term-related request2024-08-26Not public
Rectification2024-08-16Public
Rectification2024-08-16Public
Statement on service Defendant 52024-08-15Not public
Service of the action to Defendant 52024-08-14Not public
Opportunity to comment2024-08-14Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2024-08-14Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-08-14Not public
Closing of the workflow2024-08-14Public
Confidentiality order2024-08-14Public
Confidentiality order2024-08-14Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-08-14Not public
Closing of the workflow2024-08-14Public
Confidentiality order2024-08-14Public
Confidentiality order2024-08-14Not public
Application for Intervene - oportunity to comment2024-08-13Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-08-12Not public
Receipt2024-08-12Not public
2024_08_12 Brief of NEC Response to confidentiality circle - A169308VLU22 - signed.pdf2024-08-12Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-08-12Not public
20240812_Noerr_Request_confidentiality_RoP_262A_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_22024-08-12Not public
20240812_Noerr_Request_confidentiality_RoP_262_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_22024-08-12Not public
20240812_Noerr_Statement_re_RoP_262A_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-08-12Not public
Annex_DF_202024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_272024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_232024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_612024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17a2024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_212024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_262024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_192024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_142024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_102024-08-09Not public
20240812_Noerr_Statement_of_Defense_FRAND_Defendant_2_595922_20232024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_182024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_112024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17d2024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_012024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_152024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_312024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_042024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_312024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_292024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_602024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_022024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_032024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_172024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_322024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_082024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_272024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17c2024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_322024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_092024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_102024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_202024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17b2024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_302024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_132024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_332024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17a2024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_162024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_012024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_192024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_082024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_342024-08-09Not public
20240812_Noerr_Statement_of_Defense_FRAND_Defendant_2_595922_20232024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_262024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_292024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_282024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_062024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_052024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17d2024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_112024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_092024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17c2024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_042024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_352024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_122024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_122024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_032024-08-09Not public
20240812_Noerr_Statement_of_Defense_Technical_Defendant_2_595922_20232024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_222024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_212024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_152024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_142024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_072024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_192024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_252024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_282024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_242024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_072024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_062024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_302024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_132024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_212024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_202024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_232024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_252024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_162024-08-09Not public
Annex_D_242024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_582024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_022024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_222024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_172024-08-09Not public
Annex_DF_17b2024-08-09Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-08-07Not public
Notification Of Service2024-08-06Not public
Proof of service2024-08-06Not public
262A Note2024-08-06Not public
Notification of service2024-08-06Public
Annex DF 612024-07-31Not public
Noerr_Statement_RoP_262A_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-31Not public
Annex DF 602024-07-31Not public
Annex DF 612024-07-31Not public
Noerr_Statement_RoP_262A_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-31Not public
Annex DF 602024-07-31Not public
Annex DF 612024-07-31Not public
Annex DF 602024-07-31Not public
Noerr_Statement_RoP_262A_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-31Not public
Noerr_Statement_RoP_262A_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-31Not public
Annex DF 602024-07-31Not public
Annex DF 612024-07-31Not public
Opportunity to comment2024-07-31Not public
Opportunity to comment2024-07-31Not public
Opportunity to comment2024-07-31Not public
Response to court order2024-07-30Not public
Notice of Service Defendant 22024-07-29Not public
PO in the main proceedings2024-07-29Public
A169308VLU22 2024-07-25 Brief of NEC statement to confidentiality - TCL Deutschland_signiert.pdf2024-07-25Not public
A169308VLU22 2024-07-25 Brief of NEC re statement to confidentiality - TCT Mobile germany, Europe, Polska_signiert2024-07-25Not public
Receipt2024-07-17Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-07-17Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05b - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 2).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03h - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail an TCL Com).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03f - NEC (HEVC Advance - E-Mail 2.10.2018).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01f - NEC (TCL Communication).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03 - NEC (LG Munich Judgement_redacted).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 List of exhibits.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03i - NEC (Standard-Lizenzvertrag).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01e - NEC (TCT Mobile Europe).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 04 - NEC (EP2645714).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02b - NEC (Struktur der Pool Lizenzgeb. EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 06 - NEC (HEVC-Standard_201003-S).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03e - NEC (TCL - E-Mail 23.7.2018).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01f - NEC (TCL Communication).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02c - NEC (Explanation of HEVC Advance Rates).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 04 - NEC (EP2645714).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 04a - NEC (Patent_Registers).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05d - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 4).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02c - NEC (Explanation of HEVC Advance Rates).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05a - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 1).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 07 - NEC (Memo PRC Law KWM).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 04 - NEC (EP2645714).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 04b - NEC (Feature Analysis EP714).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03d - NEC (Lowenstein Sandler).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01g - NEC (IFA Exhibitors).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03b - NEC (HEVC Advance 22.09.2016 EN).PDF2024-07-17Not public
2024_07_17 Brief of NEC re missing documents - A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02d - NEC (Licensing_Landscape EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02a - NEC (Advance Overview EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02a - NEC (Advance Overview EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01d - NEC (TCT Mobile Germany).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05c - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 3).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05a - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 1).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01g - NEC (IFA Exhibitors).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03h - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail an TCL Com).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Submitting UPC court fees.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03d - NEC (Lowenstein Sandler).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 04b - NEC (Feature Analysis EP714).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 07 - NEC (Memo PRC Law KWM).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Complaint - NEC-TCL_signiert.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03b - NEC (HEVC Advance 22.09.2016 EN).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Submitting UPC court fees.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01e - NEC (TCT Mobile Europe).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03i - NEC (Standard-Lizenzvertrag).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03j - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail Claimcharts).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Complaint - NEC-TCL_signiert.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05c - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 3).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01c - NEC (Industries Holding EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05b - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 2).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 05d - NEC (Screenshots Beklagte zu 4).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01d - NEC (TCT Mobile Germany).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03a - NEC (HEVC Advance 27.5.2016 EN).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 04a - NEC (Patent_Registers).pdf2024-07-17Not public
2024_07_17 Brief of NEC re missing documents - A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02b - NEC (Struktur der Pool Lizenzgeb. EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03g - NEC (Access Advance - E-Mail 26.10.2020).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 List of exhibits.pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01b - NEC (HRA Instagram TCL Deutschland GmbH)2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01c - NEC (Industries Holding EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 02d - NEC (Licensing_Landscape EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03 - NEC (LG Munich Judgement_redacted).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 06 - NEC (HEVC-Standard_201003-S).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01a - NEC (TCL Group EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01b - NEC (HRA Instagram TCL Deutschland GmbH)2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03a - NEC (HEVC Advance 27.5.2016 EN).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03f - NEC (HEVC Advance - E-Mail 2.10.2018).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03e - NEC (TCL - E-Mail 23.7.2018).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03c - NEC (HEVC Advance 25.09.2017 EN).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 01a - NEC (TCL Group EN).pdf2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03c - NEC (HEVC Advance 25.09.2017 EN).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03j - NEC (Access Advance E-Mail Claimcharts).PDF2024-07-17Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP 03g - NEC (Access Advance - E-Mail 26.10.2020).PDF2024-07-17Not public
Statement of Claim upload2024-07-15Public
Receipt2024-07-12Not public
Receipt2024-07-12Not public
Request_confidentiality_RoP_262_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-12Not public
Request_confidentiality_RoP_262_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-12Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-12Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-07-12Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-12Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-07-12Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-12Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-07-12Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-12Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-07-12Not public
Preliminary Order - 262A - B 3-4-62024-07-11Not public
Preliminary Order - 262A - Defendant 12024-07-11Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-10Not public
Redacted SoD FRAND2024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-10Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-10Not public
Response to Request for Amendments2024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-10Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-10Not public
Response to Request for Amendments2024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-10Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-10Not public
Redacted SoD FRAND2024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-10Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-10Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-10Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-10Not public
Response to Request for Amendments2024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-10Not public
Redacted SoD FRAND2024-07-10Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-10Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-10Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-10Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-10Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-10Not public
Response to Request for Amendments2024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-10Not public
Redacted SoD Defendant 12024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-10Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-10Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-10Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-10Not public
Confidentiality Request for Defendant 3 4 and 62024-07-10Not public
Confidentiality Request Defendant 12024-07-10Not public
Formal-checks_Request-for-correction2024-07-09Not public
Formal-checks_Request-for-correction2024-07-09Not public
Formal-checks_Request-for-correction2024-07-09Not public
Formal-checks_Request-for-correction2024-07-09Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-08Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-08Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_Technical_Defendants_1_3_4_6_595922_20232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendants_3_4_62024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annes_DF_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_102024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_392024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_502024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_462024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_572024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_582024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_22024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_382024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_132024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_242024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_442024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_112024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_542024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_512024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_062024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_182024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_222024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_322024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_552024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_592024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_522024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_342024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_082024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_252024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_142024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_192024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_472024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_412024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_022024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_352024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_162024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_422024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_372024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_262024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_152024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_402024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_012024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_352024-07-08Not public
Noerr_Statement_of_Defence_Counterclaim_FRAND_595922_2023_Defendant_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_212024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_432024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_362024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_302024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_48_12024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_232024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_052024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_032024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_452024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_492024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_332024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_122024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_562024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_312024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_282024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_292024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_072024-07-08Not public
Annex_D_202024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_092024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_172024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_272024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_532024-07-08Not public
Annex_DN_042024-07-08Not public
Annex_DF_052024-07-08Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-07-03Not public
FVA Defence Withdraw2024-07-03Public
Outcome of the Order2024-07-02Not public
Withdrawal Request Disclosure2024-07-02Public
Noerr_request_595922_20232024-07-02Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-07-02Not public
FVA Defence Withdrawal2024-07-02Public
Receipt2024-07-02Not public
Noerr_request_595922_20232024-07-02Not public
Statement Extension of deadline request2024-07-01Not public
Receipt2024-07-01Not public
Noerr_request_deadline_extension_595922_2023_App_25792_20242024-06-28Not public
Preliminary Order Disclosure2024-06-28Not public
commentPreliminaryObjection2024-06-25Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP16a - NEC Opinion of CJEU EN.pdf2024-06-25Not public
2024_06_25 Brief of NEC - statement to preliminary objection - A169308VLU22_signiert.pdf2024-06-25Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP16b - NEC Judgement of the court EN.pdf2024-06-25Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-06-12Not public
preliminaryObjection2024-06-11Not public
Annex D 112024-06-11Not public
Annex D 82024-06-11Not public
Annex D 162024-06-11Not public
Annex D 22024-06-11Not public
Annex D 52024-06-11Not public
Annex D 182024-06-11Not public
Annex D 102024-06-11Not public
Annex D 122024-06-11Not public
Annex D 92024-06-11Not public
Annex D 72024-06-11Not public
Annex D 152024-06-11Not public
Annex D 32024-06-11Not public
Annex D 42024-06-11Not public
Annex D 172024-06-11Not public
Preliminary Objection Defendant 22024-06-11Not public
Annex D 62024-06-11Not public
Annex D 142024-06-11Not public
Annex D 132024-06-11Not public
Annex D 12024-06-11Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-06-11Not public
Noerr_Statement_App_25792_20242024-06-04Not public
Noerr_Statement_App_25792_20242024-06-04Not public
Noerr_Statement_App_25792_20242024-06-04Not public
Noerr_Statement_App_25792_20242024-06-04Not public
Further comment on App_25792-20242024-05-29Not public
Preliminary_Objection_DecisionOutcome2024-05-29Not public
Preliminary Objection RoP 20.22024-05-29Public
A169308VLU22 Brief of NEC statement re disclosure of license FRAND dd May 27 2024_signiert.pdf2024-05-27Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-05-24Not public
New deadline SoD2024-05-24Public
A169308VLU22 Brief of NEC statement re time limits dd May 15 2024_signiert.pdf2024-05-15Not public
Receipt2024-05-15Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-05-15Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-05-15Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP6-corrected.pdf2024-05-15Not public
A169308VLU22 Brief of NEC - Transmission of corrected exhibit BP 6 dd May 15 2024_signiert.pdf2024-05-15Not public
A169308VLU22 Exhibit BP6-corrected.pdf2024-05-15Not public
A169308VLU22 Brief of NEC - Transmission of corrected exhibit BP 6 dd May 15 2024_signiert.pdf2024-05-15Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-05-15Not public
workstream closed2024-05-15Public
Outcome of the Order2024-05-15Not public
missing appendixes2024-05-15Public
R 9 deadlines - comments (2)2024-05-15Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-05-15Not public
service2024-05-15Public
Receipt2024-05-13Not public
Noerr_Comment and Rule 9.3 request deadline extension_595922_20232024-05-13Not public
Noerr_Comment and Rule 9.3 request deadline extension_595922_20232024-05-13Not public
Noerr_Comment and Rule 9.3 request deadline extension_595922_20232024-05-13Not public
Noerr_Comment and Rule 9.3 request deadline extension_595922_20232024-05-13Not public
Receipt2024-05-10Not public
Request for order2024-05-08Not public
Application 07-05-20242024-05-08Not public
Receipt2024-05-07Not public
Application for disclosure order2024-05-07Not public
Request to shorten the SoD deadline2024-05-06Not public
Receipt2024-05-02Not public
A169308VLU22 Brief of NEC - deadline request_signed.pdf2024-05-02Not public
Receipt2024-04-19Not public
A169308VLU22 Request Rule 9 - NEC April 18 2024_signiert.pdf2024-04-19Not public
A169308VLU22 Complaint - NEC-TCL_signiert ursprünglich eingereicht am 221223.pdf2024-04-19Not public
A169308VLU22 Statement of claim - NEC_signiert.pdf2024-04-19Not public
Confirmation of notification of appointment2024-04-16Not public
Proof of service2024-04-16Not public
Confirmation of notification of appointment2024-04-16Not public
Proof of service2024-04-16Not public
commentPreliminaryObjection2024-04-08Not public
Exhibit BP15c - NEC Judgement of the court EN.pdf2024-04-08Not public
Brief of NEC - Response to Preliminary Objection2024-04-08Not public
Exhibit BP15a - NEC Opinion of CJEU2024-04-08Not public
Exhibit BP15b - NEC Administrative Committee EN.pdf2024-04-08Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-03-27Not public
RoP 9 Request2024-03-27Public
Notification Of Service2024-03-26Not public
Proof of service2024-03-26Not public
Receipt2024-03-25Not public
preliminaryObjection2024-03-25Not public
D22024-03-22Not public
D62024-03-22Not public
D102024-03-22Not public
D12024-03-22Not public
D42024-03-22Not public
D52024-03-22Not public
D72024-03-22Not public
Preliminary Objections2024-03-22Not public
D92024-03-22Not public
D32024-03-22Not public
D82024-03-22Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-03-21Not public
Representation Notice2024-03-21Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-03-19Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-03-19Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-03-06Not public
correction addresses2024-03-06Public
Outcome of the Order2024-03-06Not public
correction addresses2024-03-06Public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-03-05Not public
Receipt2024-03-05Not public
Brief of NEC dd March 5 2024_signiert2024-03-05Not public
Exhibit BP 14 HR Excerpt TCT Mobile Germany GmbH2024-03-05Not public
Receipt2024-03-04Not public
A169308VLU22 Brief of NEC - correction of caption_signiert.pdf2024-03-04Not public
Letter for Service2024-02-19Not public
Letter for Service2024-02-19Not public
Letter for Service2024-02-19Not public
Notification Of Service2024-02-16Not public
Proof of Service2024-02-16Not public
Outcome of the Order2024-02-05Not public
Order App_3482-20232024-02-05Not public
Receipt2024-01-23Not public
Exhibit_BP11.pdf2024-01-23Not public
Exhibit_BP10.pdf2024-01-23Not public
Exhibit_BP9.pdf2024-01-23Not public
A169308VLU22 Brief of NEC - Request altern. Service dd January 22 2024_signiert.pdf2024-01-23Not public
Exhibit_BP12.pdf2024-01-23Not public
Exhibit_BP8.pdf2024-01-23Not public
Exhibit_BP13.pdf2024-01-23Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-05Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-05Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-05Not public
Letter for Service2024-01-05Not public
epoUploadDocumentsWorkflow2024-01-05Not public
Document from EPO2024-01-05Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-01-04Not public
EPO-Request-for-case-pending2024-01-02Not public
Receipt2024-01-02Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-01-02Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 1a TCL Group EN.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3a HEVC Advance 27.5.2016 EN.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 4a_Patent_Registers.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 2b Struktur der Pool Lizenzgebuehren EN.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 5b Screenshots Beklagte zu 2.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 1b HRA Instagram TCL Deutschland GmbH.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3b HEVC Advance 22.09.2016 EN.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3j_Access Advance E-Mail Claimcharts.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 2d Licensing_Landscape EN.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 1d TCT Mobile Germany.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3 LG Munich Judgement_redacted2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 1f TCL Communication.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 6 HEVC-Standard_201003-S.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3h_Access Advance E-Mail an TCL Com.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 5c Screenshots Beklagte zu 3.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 1e TCT Mobile Europe.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3c HEVC Advance 25.09.2017 EN.PDF2023-12-22Not public
A169308VLU22 - UPC court fees.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Liste of exhibits.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3i_Standard-Lizenzvertrag.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3g_Access Advance - E-Mail 26.10.2020.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3d Lowenstein Sandler.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 1c Industries Holding EN.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 5d Screenshots Beklagte zu 4.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 5a Screenshots Beklagte zu 1.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 1g IFA Exhibitors.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 2a Advance Overview EN.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 4_EP2645714.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 2c Explanation of HEVC Advance Rates.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 4b_Feature Analysis EP714.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 7 Memo PRC Law KWM.pdf2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3f_HEVC Advance - E-Mail 2.10.2018.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Complaint NEC-TCL2023-12-22Not public
Exhibit BP 3e_TCL - E-Mail 23.7.2018.PDF2023-12-22Not public
Coverage: Thin.Reasoning extracted with limited coverage — see decisions tab for full text.
Plain-English summary

NEC Corporation filed an infringement action against TCL entities at the Munich Local Division regarding EP 2 645 714 (a video decoding patent), with Access Advance LLC as intervener. The parties reached a contractual settlement before the closure of the written procedure, and NEC withdrew the action in January 2025. The court confirmed the withdrawal, ordered 60% reimbursement of court fees to NEC (EUR 14,400), and recorded that each party bears its own costs.

Accepted arguments
What the court agreed with — by party.

No accepted arguments captured.

Rejected arguments
What the court did not agree with — and why.

No rejected arguments captured.

Key legal principles
Doctrines and rules cited in the reasoning.
withdrawal of infringement action permissible when parties reach contractual agreement before closure of written procedure under R. 265.1 RoP60% reimbursement of court fees on withdrawal before closure of written procedure under R. 370.9(b)(i) RoPcost agreement between parties taken into account under R. 265.2(c) RoP

Browse other cases on this principle.