UPC Analytics
ENDE
Overview · Filed: Dec 27, 2023

UPC_CFI_501/2023

PROSTHETIC HEART VALVE

InfringementMain Infringement ActionMunich LDInfringementCase Closed
Parties

Claimants

Reps: Boris Kreye

Respondents

Reps: Hans-Roman Würtenberger
Judges
  • Matthias Zigann
  • Margot Kokke
  • Tobias Pichlmaier
  • Stefan Wilhelm
Patents
  • EP3669828
  • EP 3 669 828
CPC codes: A61F2220/0075, A61F2/2418, A61F2230/0054, A61F2250/0069, A61F2/2412, A61F2250/0097, A61F2/2433, A61F2250/0036

Technology area: Medical Devices · Implants

Sector: Pharmaceutical & Medical

Outcome
InfringedInfringed
Filed: Dec 27, 2023
First decided:
Language: English

Infringement action by Edwards Lifesciences Corporation against Meril GmbH, Meril Life Sciences Pvt Ltd, and Meril Italy S.r.l. concerning transcatheter heart valve (Myval THV) and EP 3 669 828. The court found infringement, dismissed the invalidity counterclaim (patent valid), and ordered: injunction, recall, seizure and destruction, disclosure of sales data, provisional damages of EUR 663,000, publication of decision in five media outlets. Decision immediately and directly enforceable from date of service. Key headnotes: jurisdiction for multiple defendants with commercial relationship; problem-solution approach for inventive step; cease-and-desist without penalty clause insufficient.

Open on UPC Registry
Claims
At issueall
Infringedall
Notes: Munich LD found Meril entities infringe EP3669828 (prosthetic heart valve); invalidity counterclaim dismissed; injunction, recall, and provisional damages of EUR 663,000 ordered; specific claim numbers not enumerated in excerpt.