UPClytics
EnglishDeutsch
Sign inSign up
View all cases

UPC CFI 557/2024

Sep 27, 2024·EP3198245: A SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR MONITORING FOOD WASTE

Parent infringement case:UPC CFI 327/2024

Case details
Status
Written Phase
Action
Counterclaim for revocation
Category
Counter Claim for Revocation
Parties
Claimants
Reps: Michiel de Baat
Respondents
Reps: Gregory Bacon
Division
The Hague LD
Judges
Technology
Software & Computing · AI/ML · Computing & AI
Language
English
Documents
Document titleDatePublic
action.phaseChange.caseClose2026-04-01Not public
Headnote-and-Keywords2025-08-13Not public
20250813 - Winnow_Orbisk final signed-anon2025-08-13Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-08-13Not public
final decision2025-08-13Not public
final decision2025-08-13Public
Comments on R.190 Evidence2025-06-16Not public
Exhibit 2 - R.190 Evidence provided by Winnow2025-06-16Not public
Exhibit 2 - R.190 Evidence provided by Winnow2025-06-16Not public
Exhibit 1 - R.190 Evidence provided by Winnow2025-06-16Not public
Exhibit 1 - R.190 Evidence provided by Winnow2025-06-16Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-06-11Not public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Not public
Outcome of the Order2025-06-11Not public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Public
Outcome of the Order2025-06-11Not public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Public
Outcome of the Order2025-06-11Not public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Public
order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-11Public
Preliminary order Winnows v Orbisk on IC hearing2025-06-04Not public
R. 262A application2025-05-12Not public
Rejoin-Amend-Patent-Defence2025-05-12Not public
DE44.B - Japanese patent application JPS6378023A (certified translation)2025-05-12Not public
R. 30 Rejoinder2025-05-12Not public
DE47 PR-6 - Documents relating to PCD2025-05-12Not public
DE47 - Second Expert statement emeritus professor Peter Rem of 12 May 20252025-05-12Not public
R. 30 Rejoinder2025-05-12Not public
Receipt2025-04-17Not public
D13 - Confidentiality request with respect to the R263 and R190 Reply2025-04-17Not public
DE46 - Corporate information Restaurant Associates and Compass Group2025-04-17Not public
D12 - R263 and R190 Reply2025-04-17Not public
DE45 - Case studies on Branocs Tree Hungy Horse pub and Crieff Hydro of 27 November 20142025-04-17Not public
D12 - R263 and R190 Reply2025-04-17Not public
D13 - Confidentiality request with respect to the R263 and R190 Reply2025-04-17Not public
Response to a Request for Order to Produce Evidence Under Rule 190 RoP2025-04-11Not public
Reply-Amend-Patent-Defence2025-04-11Not public
Annex 4 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex NF-2 to Expert Report of Prof Fleck2025-04-11Not public
Annex 6 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex 1 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex 3 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Rejoinder and R.30(2) application2025-04-11Not public
Annex 5 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex NF-1 to Expert Report of Prof Fleck2025-04-11Not public
Annex 2 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Receipt2025-04-11Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2025-04-11Not public
Annex 1 to Rejoinder - Claim amendments (MR and CRs)2025-04-11Not public
Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex 6 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex 3 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex 2 to Rejoinder - Expert Report of Prof Norman Fleck2025-04-11Not public
Annex 5 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex 4 to Rejoinder2025-04-11Not public
Annex 1 to Rejoinder - application for amendments R30(2)2025-04-11Not public
Rejoinder and R.30(2) application2025-04-11Not public
Application under r262 and r262A2025-04-09Not public
Annex 2 CONFIDENTIAL2025-04-09Not public
Annex 3 CONFIDENTIAL2025-04-09Not public
Annex 2 CONFIDENTIAL2025-04-09Not public
Annex 12025-04-09Not public
Response to Application for Leave2025-04-09Not public
r262 and r262A Application2025-04-09Not public
Annex 3 CONFIDENTIAL2025-04-09Not public
Annex 4 CONFIDENTIAL2025-04-09Not public
Annex 4 CONFIDENTIAL2025-04-09Not public
Panel-Appointment2025-04-04Not public
R. 190 preliminary order2025-04-01Not public
R. 263 preliminary order2025-04-01Not public
Receipt2025-03-11Not public
Receipt2025-03-11Not public
D11 - Confidentiality request2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-1 - CV emeritus professor PC Rem2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-5 - Excerpt of D. Pyle, "Data Preparation for Data Mining", Academic Press 19992025-03-10Not public
DE42 - Screenshots of Winnow's website via wayback machine prior to 21 April 20152025-03-10Not public
DE44.A - Machine translation by EPO of the description of JPS6378023A2025-03-10Not public
DE39 - Social media posts of Orbisk at Horecava on 7 January 20192025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-3 - Excerpt of J.F. Hair et al, "Multivariate Data Analysis", Pearson New International Edition 20142025-03-10Not public
DE40 - Expert statement emeritus professor Peter Rem of 10 March 20252025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-2 - Slides lecture 1 Data Analysis Course TU Delft 20122025-03-10Not public
DE41 - Audio transcript of the Winnow Video2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-4 - Excerpt of R. Nisbet et al, "Handbook of Statistical Analysis and Data Mining Applications", Elsevier 20092025-03-10Not public
DE44 - Japanese patent application publication JPS6378023A of Shimadzu Corporation of 8 April 19882025-03-10Not public
DE38 - Several screenshots of Winnow's website and linked pages via wayback machine prior to 20152025-03-10Not public
DE43 - A. Seymour, "Greene King drives down costs in pub chain", Foodservice Equipment Journal, 18 March 20152025-03-10Not public
D10 - Rejoinder in the main action, reply in the counterclaim2025-03-10Not public
DE42 - Screenshots of Winnow's website via wayback machine prior to 21 April 20152025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-1 - CV emeritus professor PC Rem2025-03-10Not public
D11 - Confidentiality request2025-03-10Not public
DE44.A - Machine translation by EPO of the description of JPS6378023A2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-4 - Excerpt of R. Nisbet et al, "Handbook of Statistical Analysis and Data Mining Applications", Elsevier 20092025-03-10Not public
D10 - Rejoinder in the main action, reply in the counterclaim2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-2 - Slides lecture 1 Data Analysis Course TU Delft 20122025-03-10Not public
DE40 - Expert statement emeritus professor Peter Rem of 10 March 20252025-03-10Not public
DE43 - A. Seymour, "Greene King drives down costs in pub chain", Foodservice Equipment Journal, 18 March 20152025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-5 - Excerpt of D. Pyle, "Data Preparation for Data Mining", Academic Press 19992025-03-10Not public
DE38 - Several screenshots of Winnow's website and linked pages via wayback machine prior to 20152025-03-10Not public
DE41 - Audio transcript of the Winnow Video2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-3 - Excerpt of J.F. Hair et al, "Multivariate Data Analysis", Pearson New International Edition 20142025-03-10Not public
DE44 - Japanese patent application publication JPS6378023A of Shimadzu Corporation of 8 April 19882025-03-10Not public
DE39 - Social media posts of Orbisk at Horecava on 7 January 20192025-03-10Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2025-03-10Not public
Rejoinder in the main action, reply in the counterclaim2025-03-10Not public
DE39 - Social media posts of Orbisk at Horecava on 7 January 20192025-03-10Not public
DE44.A - Machine translation by EPO of the description of JPS6378023A2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-1 - CV emeritus professor PC Rem2025-03-10Not public
DE41 - Audio transcript of the Winnow Video2025-03-10Not public
DE44 - Japanese patent application publication JPS6378023A of Shimadzu Corporation of 8 April 19882025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-2 - Slides lecture 1 Data Analysis Course TU Delft 20122025-03-10Not public
Confidentiality request2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-3 - Excerpt of J.F. Hair et al, "Multivariate Data Analysis", Pearson New International Edition 20142025-03-10Not public
DE42 - Screenshots of Winnow's website via wayback machine prior to 21 April 20152025-03-10Not public
DE43 - A. Seymour, "Greene King drives down costs in pub chain", Foodservice Equipment Journal, 18 March 20152025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-5 - Excerpt of D. Pyle, "Data Preparation for Data Mining", Academic Press 19992025-03-10Not public
DE40 - Expert statement emeritus professor Peter Rem of 10 March 20252025-03-10Not public
DE38 - Several screenshots of Winnow's website and linked pages via wayback machine prior to 20152025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-4 - Excerpt of R. Nisbet et al, "Handbook of Statistical Analysis and Data Mining Applications", Elsevier 20092025-03-10Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2025-03-10Not public
DE43 - A. Seymour, "Greene King drives down costs in pub chain", Foodservice Equipment Journal, 18 March 20152025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-4 - Excerpt of R. Nisbet et al, "Handbook of Statistical Analysis and Data Mining Applications", Elsevier 20092025-03-10Not public
DE38 - Several screenshots of Winnow's website and linked pages via wayback machine prior to 20152025-03-10Not public
DE39 - Social media posts of Orbisk at Horecava on 7 January 20192025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-5 - Excerpt of D. Pyle, "Data Preparation for Data Mining", Academic Press 19992025-03-10Not public
Confidentiality request2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-1 - CV emeritus professor PC Rem2025-03-10Not public
DE44.A - Machine translation by EPO of the description of JPS6378023A2025-03-10Not public
DE42 - Screenshots of Winnow's website via wayback machine prior to 21 April 20152025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-3 - Excerpt of J.F. Hair et al, "Multivariate Data Analysis", Pearson New International Edition 20142025-03-10Not public
DE44 - Japanese patent application publication JPS6378023A of Shimadzu Corporation of 8 April 19882025-03-10Not public
Rejoinder in the main action, reply in the counterclaim2025-03-10Not public
DE40 PR-2 - Slides lecture 1 Data Analysis Course TU Delft 20122025-03-10Not public
DE40 - Expert statement emeritus professor Peter Rem of 10 March 20252025-03-10Not public
DE41 - Audio transcript of the Winnow Video2025-03-10Not public
Receipt2025-02-04Not public
Receipt2025-02-04Not public
R. 9 Request2025-02-03Not public
DE37 - Email Bristows 28 November 20242025-02-03Not public
DE37 - Email Bristows 28 November 20242025-02-03Not public
R. 9 Request2025-02-03Not public
setting IC and OH dates2025-01-31Public
Hearing-Dates2025-01-31Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-12-23Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-12-23Not public
Annex 7 - Third Conditional Request (application to amend)2024-12-23Not public
Annex 5 - Second Conditional Request (application to amend)2024-12-23Not public
Annex 6 - Conditional Request 2A (application to amend)2024-12-23Not public
Annex 3 - Main Request (application amend)2024-12-23Not public
Annex 4 - First Conditional Request (application to amend)2024-12-23Not public
Annex 8 - Conditional Request 3A (application to amend)2024-12-23Not public
Annex 10 - Conditional Request 3C (application to amend)2024-12-23Not public
Reply to Defence and Defence to Counterclaim2024-12-23Not public
Annex 9 - Conditional Request 3B (application to amend)2024-12-23Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-12-23Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-12-23Not public
Reply to Defence and Defence to Counterclaim2024-12-23Not public
epoUploadDocumentsWorkflow2024-10-17Not public
Document from EPO2024-10-11Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-10-10Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-10-08Not public
Acknowledgement of access to case2024-10-08Not public
Notification Of Service2024-10-08Not public
Letter-for-Service2024-10-08Not public
Panel-Appointment2024-10-08Not public
EPO-Request-for-case-pending2024-10-08Not public
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2024-10-08Not public
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2024-10-08Not public
DE18 - LeanPath's United States patent US 7,415,375,B22024-10-04Not public
DE11 - A. Cassidy, Guardian article about the Winnow System..., The Guardian, 15 May 20182024-10-04Not public
DE19 - Presentation by mr. Shakman (CEO of LeanPath) entitled "Food Waste Tracking:...", at the NRA Show 20102024-10-04Not public
DE22 - United States patent application US 2008/0357692024-10-04Not public
DE13 - Various Twitter posts of FoodSave about sales of the Winnow System as of 2 April 20142024-10-04Not public
DE23 - Brochure of Avery Weigh-Tronix regarding the M725 Data Management System of 20022024-10-04Not public
DE01 - Original application EP 3 198 245 filed on 21 April 20152024-10-04Not public
DE05 - Video about the Winnow System dated February 20152024-10-04Not public
Statement of defense also counterclaim for revocation including corrected formalities2024-10-04Not public
DE20 - Presentation by mr. Shakman (CEO of LeanPath) entitled "The Virtues of Now:...", at TDWI on 4 March 20132024-10-04Not public
DE21.E - Recycling Today article on BioHiTech's Eco-Safe Digester entitled "BioHiTech digester..., dated 11/09/20142024-10-04Not public
DE25 - K. Morris, "LeanPath Weighs In", Embedded Technology Journal, 8 May 20072024-10-04Not public
DE06 - T. Dasu and T. Johnson, "Exploratory Data Mining and Data Cleaning", Wiley 20032024-10-04Not public
DE24 - Literature and screenshots on data cleaning Microsoft Access2024-10-04Not public
DE21.A - Various screenshots of BioHiTech's website in relation to the Eco-Safe Digester, dated 11 March 20152024-10-04Not public
DE21.B - Various screenshots of BioHiTech's website in relation to the Cloud, dated 6 February 20152024-10-04Not public
D3 - Statement of Defence2024-10-04Not public
DE10 - V. Lim et al., "Eco-Feedback for Non-Consumption", 13 September 20142024-10-04Not public
DE03 - Chinese utility model application CN203324802U of Guangzhou Eastsoft Technology Co Ltd. published on 4/12/20132024-10-04Not public
DE26 - Relevant pages from the prosecution file of the Patent2024-10-04Not public
DE02 - Priority document US 61/982,012 filed on 21 April 20142024-10-04Not public
DE15 - Service instruction manual of Avery Berkel's programmable indicator L240 dated 14 November 20022024-10-04Not public
DE21.D - New Atlas article on BioHiTech's Eco-Safe Digester entitled "EcoSafe: Big data less waste", dated 2/12/20142024-10-04Not public
DE07 - J.M. Hellerstein, "Quantitative Data Cleaning for Large Databases", 27 February 20082024-10-04Not public
DE03.A - Chinese utility model application CN203324802U (certified translation)2024-10-04Not public
DE09 - J. Warwick, "Restaurants turning to high-tech solutions to save money and food", The Guardian 28 March 20142024-10-04Not public
DE16 - Brochure of Avery Weigh-Tronix entitled "Waste & Recycling Weighing Systems" of 20132024-10-04Not public
DE21.C - Various screenshots of BioHiTech's video of the Eco-Safe Digester2024-10-04Not public
DE14 - Various screenshots in relation to Winnow's video about its second-generation product Winnow Vision2024-10-04Not public
DE08 - Korhonen et al., "Waste container weighing...", Waste Management 39 (2015) 15-252024-10-04Not public
DE17 - Brochure of LeanPath's ValueWaste Food Waste Tracker of 20062024-10-04Not public
DE12 - M. Zornes, "Food Save - reducing food waste with the SRA", blog post on winnowsolutions.com dated 31 March 20142024-10-04Not public
DE04 - Various screenshots in relation to Winnow's video about the Winnow System2024-10-04Not public
Formal-checks_Request-for-correction2024-10-04Not public
DE10 - V. Lim et al., "Eco-Feedback for Non-Consumption", 13 September 20142024-09-27Not public
DE20 - Presentation by mr. Shakman (CEO of LeanPath) entitled "The Virtues of Now:...", at TDWI on 4 March 20132024-09-27Not public
DE25 - K. Morris, "LeanPath Weighs In", Embedded Technology Journal, 8 May 20072024-09-27Not public
DE21.E - Recycling Today article on BioHiTech's Eco-Safe Digester entitled "BioHiTech digester..., dated 11/09/20142024-09-27Not public
DE17 - Brochure of LeanPath's ValueWaste Food Waste Tracker of 20062024-09-27Not public
DE02 - Priority document US 61/982,012 filed on 21 April 20142024-09-27Not public
DE22 - United States patent application US 2008/0357692024-09-27Not public
DE08 - Korhonen et al., "Waste container weighing...", Waste Management 39 (2015) 15-252024-09-27Not public
DE01 - Original application EP 3 198 245 filed on 21 April 20152024-09-27Not public
DE03.A - Chinese utility model application CN203324802U (certified translation)2024-09-27Not public
DE07 - J.M. Hellerstein, "Quantitative Data Cleaning for Large Databases", 27 February 20082024-09-27Not public
DE23 - Brochure of Avery Weigh-Tronix regarding the M725 Data Management System of 20022024-09-27Not public
DE15 - Service instruction manual of Avery Berkel's programmable indicator L240 dated 14 November 20022024-09-27Not public
DE05 - Video about the Winnow System dated February 20152024-09-27Not public
DE21.B - Various screenshots of BioHiTech's website in relation to the Cloud, dated 6 February 20152024-09-27Not public
DE24 - Literature and screenshots on data cleaning Microsoft Access2024-09-27Not public
DE16 - Brochure of Avery Weigh-Tronix entitled "Waste & Recycling Weighing Systems" of 20132024-09-27Not public
DE26 - Relevant pages from the prosecution file of the Patent2024-09-27Not public
DE09 - J. Warwick, "Restaurants turning to high-tech solutions to save money and food", The Guardian 28 March 20142024-09-27Not public
D3 - Statement of Defence2024-09-27Not public
DE03 - Chinese utility model application CN203324802U of Guangzhou Eastsoft Technology Co Ltd. published on 4/12/20132024-09-27Not public
DE21.D - New Atlas article on BioHiTech's Eco-Safe Digester entitled "EcoSafe: Big data less waste", dated 2/12/20142024-09-27Not public
DE18 - LeanPath's United States patent US 7,415,375,B22024-09-27Not public
DE06 - T. Dasu and T. Johnson, "Exploratory Data Mining and Data Cleaning", Wiley 20032024-09-27Not public
DE13 - Various Twitter posts of FoodSave about sales of the Winnow System as of 2 April 20142024-09-27Not public
DE14 - Various screenshots in relation to Winnow's video about its second-generation product Winnow Vision2024-09-27Not public
DE21.A - Various screenshots of BioHiTech's website in relation to the Eco-Safe Digester, dated 11 March 20152024-09-27Not public
DE21.C - Various screenshots of BioHiTech's video of the Eco-Safe Digester2024-09-27Not public
DE04 - Various screenshots in relation to Winnow's video about the Winnow System2024-09-27Not public
DE19 - Presentation by mr. Shakman (CEO of LeanPath) entitled "Food Waste Tracking:...", at the NRA Show 20102024-09-27Not public
DE12 - M. Zornes, "Food Save - reducing food waste with the SRA", blog post on winnowsolutions.com dated 31 March 20142024-09-27Not public
DE11 - A. Cassidy, Guardian article about the Winnow System..., The Guardian, 15 May 20182024-09-27Not public