ENDE

Account

Analytics 1Cases 1Decisions 4Judges 5Parties 2Firms

Filters

Case number

Patent number

Filing date

→

Decision date

→

Division

Language

Category

Subcategory

Substantive (main) cases only

Proceeding type

Action type

Status

Outcome

Outcome detail

Motion type

Settlement timing

Technology (L1)

Technology sector

CPC code

SEP / FRAND

Judge

Claimant

Respondent

Firm

Corporate group

Entity type

Has security order

Security status

Legal principle

inadmissibility of late new arguments under Rule 9.2 RoP even on the same broad issue

Cites UPC case

Cites authority

Had oral hearing

Filters

Case number

Patent number

Filing date

→

Decision date

→

Division

Language

Category

Subcategory

Substantive (main) cases only

Proceeding type

Action type

Status

Outcome

Outcome detail

Motion type

Settlement timing

Technology (L1)

Technology sector

CPC code

SEP / FRAND

Judge

Claimant

Respondent

Firm

Corporate group

Entity type

Has security order

Security status

Legal principle

inadmissibility of late new arguments under Rule 9.2 RoP even on the same broad issue

Cites UPC case

Cites authority

Had oral hearing

Decisions

Legal principleinadmissibility of late new arguments under Rule 9.2 RoP even on the same broad issue Clear all

Date	Case	Division	Action	Motion	Outcome	Summary
2025-07-30	ACT_3932/2024	Dusseldorf LD	Infringement Action	Infringement merits	Revoked	The Düsseldorf Local Division dismissed Headwater Research LLC's infringement action against Samsung and revoked European patent EP 3 110 069 B1 to the extent of claim 1, on the basis of a successful counterclaim for revocation; all costs were borne by the claimant. The court also rejected a new argument on added matter as inadmissible under R. 9.2 RoP.