UPC CFI 791/2024
9. Dez. 2024·EP3611989 SEP +1 more · METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR TRANSMITTING WIRELESS LOCAL AREA NETWORK INFORMATION
Hauptaktenzeichen: ACT 65376/2024
- Verfahrensdetails
- StatusCase ClosedVerfahrensartEinstweilige VerfügungKategorieEinstweilige Maßnahmen
- Parteien
- Kläger
- Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd.Unternehmen
Vertreter- Tobias J. Hessel-Clifford Chance Partnerschaft mbB
- Christian Harmsen-Bird & Bird LLP
Beklagte- Netgear Inc.Unternehmen
- Netgear International LimitedUnternehmen
- NETGEAR Deutschland GmbHUnternehmen
Vertreter- Henning Gutheil-Freshfields
- Division
- Munich LD
- Technologie
- Electrical engineeringDigital communication
- Sprache
- German
- Erste Entscheidung
- 11. Dez. 2024
| Einstweilige Verfügung erlassen | Median Tage bis zur ersten Entscheidung | |
|---|---|---|
| Gesamt-UPC | 54% (38/70) | 124 |
| Munich LD | Gesperrt | Gesperrt |
| Richter Matthias Zigann | Gesperrt | Gesperrt |
| Richter Edger Brinkman | Gesperrt | Gesperrt |
| Richter Tobias Pichlmaier | Gesperrt | Gesperrt |
Vor dem UPC: Huawei Group (62 Verfahren)·Netgear Group (20 Verfahren)
Dieser Streit umfasst 16 weitere Verfahren
CC 20512/2024·UPC CFI 152/2024·UPC CoA 36/2024·UPC CoA 44/2024·UPC CFI 168/2024 und 11 weitere
9 weitere Beklagte zum selben oder einem verwandten Patent
UPC CoA 180/2026·UPC CFI 1271/2026·UPC CFI 3450/2026·UPC CFI 3451/2026·UPC CFI 3452/2026 und 4 weitere
Starten Sie die kostenlose Testphase, um die Ausgänge zu sehen.
- 2024-12-11Application for provisional measuresÖffentlich
Zusammenfassung: The Munich Local Division granted Huawei an anti-suit/anti-enforcement injunction ordering Netgear to withdraw its anti-enforcement injunction application before a US court (C.D. Cal.) that sought to prevent Huawei from enforcing its SEP patents (EP 3 611 989 and EP 3 678 321) before the UPC, holding that such foreign proceedings violate the EU Charter right to access to justice.
Rechtsfragen anzeigen (4)
- anti-suit injunction / anti-enforcement injunction Art. 32(1)(a)(c) UPCA
- standard-essential patents FRAND
- Art. 47 EU Charter access to justice
- UPC jurisdiction for AASI
| Dokumenttitel | Datum | Öffentlich |
|---|---|---|
| Headnote-and-Keyword-Translated | 2025-01-14 | Nicht öffentlich |
| Outcome of the Order | 2025-01-13 | Nicht öffentlich |
| R 265 final | 2025-01-13 | Öffentlich |
| Receipt | 2025-01-13 | Nicht öffentlich |
| Headnote-and-Keywords | 2025-01-13 | Nicht öffentlich |
| Outcome of the Order | 2025-01-13 | Nicht öffentlich |
| R 265 final | 2025-01-13 | Öffentlich |
| 25-01-10_-_UPC_CFI_791_2024_-_Freigabe_Sicherheitsleistung_-_Huawei_vs_Netgear | 2025-01-10 | Nicht öffentlich |
| 25-01-10_-_UPC_CFI_791_2024_-_Freigabe_Sicherheitsleistung_-_Huawei_vs_Netgear | 2025-01-10 | Nicht öffentlich |
| 25-01-10_-_UPC_CFI_791_2024_-_Freigabe_Sicherheitsleistung_-_Huawei_vs_Netgear | 2025-01-10 | Nicht öffentlich |
Huawei applied for an anti-anti-suit / anti-enforcement injunction against Netgear, which had filed a US proceeding (C.D. Cal.) seeking to prevent Huawei from enforcing its SEP patents (EP 3 611 989 and EP 3 678 321) at the UPC. The Munich Local Division granted the measure, holding that the UPC has jurisdiction to issue such orders, and that foreign anti-enforcement injunctions violate the EU Charter right of access to justice (Art. 47) and constitute a tortious act under German law. Netgear was ordered to immediately withdraw its US application on pain of daily fines up to EUR 250,000.
UPC has jurisdiction under Art. 32(1)(a) and (c) UPCA to issue anti-anti-suit / anti-enforcement injunctions against foreign proceedings threatening UPC access
KlägerRechtsgrundlage: Art. 32(1)(a)(c) UPCAHinweis: The Munich Local Division established UPC subject-matter jurisdiction for AASI/AEI measures against Netgear's US court proceedings.
Foreign anti-suit and anti-enforcement injunctions violate the fundamental EU right of access to justice and constitute a tort under German law
KlägerRechtsgrundlage: Art. 47 EU Charter; Art. 2(1), 19(4) GG; § 823(1) BGBHinweis: The court found that Netgear's US AEI application before the C.D. Cal. violated Huawei's EU Charter right to access to justice and constituted an unlawful act under German tort law.
Provisional measures including requirement to withdraw the US AEI application within 24 hours are appropriate
KlägerRechtsgrundlage: Art. 62 UPCAHinweis: The court ordered Netgear to withdraw its C.D. Cal. AEI application within 24 hours of service, or face fines up to EUR 250,000 per day.
Keine zurückgewiesenen Argumente erfasst.