UPClytics
Alle Fälle anzeigen

UPC CoA 169/2025

26. Feb. 2025

Verfahrensdetails
Status
Case Closed
Verfahrensart
Berufung
Kategorie
Hauptberufung
Parteien
Beklagte
Vertreter: Johanna Flythström
Division
Court of Appeal
Sprache
English
Erste Entscheidung
11. Apr. 2025
Entscheidungen
  • 2025-04-11
    AbgewiesenBerufungsentscheidungAppeal RoP220.2

    Court of Appeal dismissed TGI Sport/Supponor's appeal against two Munich Local Division orders allowing (1) amendment of AIM Sport Vision AG's statement of claim under R. 263 RoP (to add territories including Spain and UK, and add arguments on infringement by equivalence and as intermediaries) and (2) addition of TGI Sport Virtual Limited (UK entity) as a defendant under R. 305 RoP. The Court of Appeal held that the Local Division had properly exercised its discretion within acceptable boundaries. Explanation for why amendments were not in the original pleading must be in the application body but the precise wording can be in annexes. Spain's addition was justified by the anticipation of the CJEU changing the GAT v Luk case law. The stage of proceedings was not so advanced as to tip the balance against adding TGI UK.

    Rechtsfragen:Amendment of claim (R. 263 RoP)Addition of defendant (R. 305 RoP)Discretion of court on amendment/party additionStandard of review on appealGAT v Luk case law (CJEU) and Spanish territoryInfringement by equivalenceIntermediary liability
Dokumente
DokumenttitelDatumÖffentlich
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2025-04-11Nicht öffentlich
Headnote-and-Keywords2025-04-11Nicht öffentlich
DecisionOutcome2025-04-11Nicht öffentlich
Final order2025-04-11Öffentlich
Hearing reference2025-03-26Nicht öffentlich
Hearing reference2025-03-26Nicht öffentlich
no oral hearing confirmation2025-03-26Öffentlich
Interim-Procedure-Closure2025-03-26Nicht öffentlich
Summon-Oral-Hearing2025-03-26Nicht öffentlich
no oral hearing confirmation2025-03-26Öffentlich
Interim-Conference-Decision2025-03-26Nicht öffentlich
2025-03-21 - AIM Sport - Response re oral hearing2025-03-21Nicht öffentlich
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
2025-03-20 - AIM Sport - Statement of Response2025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
HL 12025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
2025-03-20 - EP 663 - Supponor writ re written proceedings (Procedural Order dated 14 March 2025) APL_9191_20252025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
HL 12025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
2025-03-20 - EP 663 - Supponor writ re written proceedings (Procedural Order dated 14 March 2025) APL_9191_20252025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
2025-03-20 - EP 663 - Supponor writ re written proceedings (Procedural Order dated 14 March 2025) APL_9191_20252025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
HL 12025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
2025-03-20 - EP 663 - Supponor writ re written proceedings (Procedural Order dated 14 March 2025) APL_9191_20252025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
HL 12025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
HL 12025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
2025-03-20 - EP 663 - Supponor writ re written proceedings (Procedural Order dated 14 March 2025) APL_9191_20252025-03-20Nicht öffentlich
Summons to oral hearing2025-03-14Nicht öffentlich
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2025-03-05Nicht öffentlich
Panel-Appointment2025-03-05Nicht öffentlich
Receipt2025-03-05Nicht öffentlich
Formal-checks_Notification-of-positive-outcome2025-03-05Nicht öffentlich
Acknowledgement-of-lodging2025-02-26Nicht öffentlich
HL-AP 12025-02-26Nicht öffentlich
2025-02-26 - EP663 - Supponor Appeal under R. 220.2 RoP against Procedural Order dated 11 February 2025_signed2025-02-26Nicht öffentlich
HL-AP 32025-02-26Nicht öffentlich
HL-AP 22025-02-26Nicht öffentlich