APL_44633/2024

DEVICE FOR TREATING NIGHT TIME BREATHING PROBLEMS

AppealsMain AppealCourt of AppealAppeal RoP220.2—

This case cites

Authorities cited within the decisions on file for this case.

Target	Legal point	Strength	Excerpt
263	amendment of case — new arguments vs amendment	Binding	Niet elk nieuw argument is wijziging van de zaak waarvoor een partij op grond van R. 263 Pr een verzoek om verlof moet indienen.
13	statement of claim — front-loaded system	Binding	R. 13 Pr schrijft voor dat de Conclusie van eis de redenen vermeldt waarom de gestelde feiten een inbreuk op de octrooiconclusies inhouden, waaronder de juridische argumenten.
263	amendment of case — new arguments vs amendment	Binding	Not every new argument constitutes an 'amendment of a case' requiring a party to apply for leave under R. 263 RoP. An amendment of a case occurs when the nature or scope of the dispute changes.
13	statement of claim — front-loaded system	Binding	R. 13 RoP requires that the Statement of claim contains the reasons why the facts relied on constitute an infringement of the patent claims, including arguments of law.
Preamble Recital 7	front-loaded procedure — early presentation of case	Binding	This provision must be interpreted in light of the final sentence of Recital 7 of the Preamble to the Rules of Procedure, which requires parties to set out their case as early as possible in the proceedings.

Target	Legal point	Strength	Excerpt
69	claim construction — scope of protection	Binding	betreft het beroep op equivalentie in de onderhavige zaak de beschermingsomvang van het octrooi in de zin van Art. 69(1) van het Europees Octrooiverdrag en het Protocol inzake de uitleg van die bepaling.
69	claim construction — scope of protection	Binding	the equivalence argument is based on the same patent, is directed against the same products and relates to a claim feature that the respondent has specifically addressed in the Statement of claim

Cited by

Subsequent UPC decisions citing this case.

Not yet cited in another decision in our corpus.