UPC Analytics
ENDE
Overview · Filed: Nov 21, 2024

UPC_CFI_702/2024

LOCK COMPRISING A SLIDER WHICH IS FLUSH RELATIVE TO A SOLE PLATE PROVIDED WITH A RECESS FOR RECEIVING A TRANSLATION STOP OF THE SLIDER

InfringementMain Infringement ActionParis LDInfringementCase Closed
Parties

Claimants

  • IMC Créations
Reps: Renaud Gaglione; Henri Bourgeois

Respondents

  • Mul-T-Lock France
Reps: Stanislas Roux-Vaillard; Adrien Bonnet
Judges

French-seated division — individual judges anonymized.

  • Panel member (anonymized)
  • Panel member (anonymized)
  • Panel member (anonymized)
  • Panel member (anonymized)
Patents
  • EP4153830
  • EP 4 153 830
CPC codes: E05B17/049, E05B85/06, E05C1/004, E05C1/04, E05B17/2057, E05B17/0004, E05B17/2049, E05B77/44, E05B79/02

Technology area: Construction · Hardware & Locks

Outcome
InfringedInfringed
Filed: Nov 21, 2024
First decided: Jan 16, 2026
Language: French

Final decision (in French) in infringement action by IMC Créations against Mul-T-Lock France (EP 4 153 830, unitary patent - lock/padlock). Court found that the MVP 1000 padlock infringed the amended claims 1 and 6 of the unitary patent as limited. Revocation counterclaim rejected (claims 1 and 6 of the amended patent valid). Injunction and corrective measures (recall, removal from channels, destruction) ordered, with a 3-month delay before enforcement per parties' agreement. Disclosure of commercial information ordered. Mul-T-Lock to bear 90% of costs. Claims on the Swiss part of the patent rejected. Key headnotes: amended unitary patent takes effect from original grant date; national parts of European patent in non-UPC states assessed against the patent as originally granted.

Open on UPC Registry
Claims
At issue1, 6
Maintained1, 6
Amended1, 6
Infringed1, 6
Notes: MVP 1000 padlock found to infringe amended claims 1 and 6 of unitary patent EP 4 153 830; revocation counterclaim of claims 1 and 6 rejected.