Overview · Filed: —
UPC_CoA_30/2024
COMPACT SERVICE MODULE WHICH IS INTENDED FOR ELECTROLYTIC ALUMINIUM PRODUCTION PLANTS
AppealsMain AppealCourt of AppealAppeal RoP220.1—
This case cites
Authorities cited within the decisions on file for this case.
Rules of Procedure · 7
| Target | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19.1 | FRAND | Binding | 1 ORDER of the Court of Appeal of the Unified Patent Court issued on 16 January 2025 Preliminary objection concerning jurisdiction of the Court (R. 19.1 RoP) HEADNOTES: - The Court’s competence (or jurisdiction) includes a separate |
| 118.1 | jurisdiction | Binding | . If litigation is to take place in court, however, applicable rules on jurisdiction must be observed. 70. The same approach is foreseen in the RoP, where R. 118.1 RoP sets out that the Court may in a decision on the merits, if requested, order |
| 144 | procedural | Binding | ceedings for determining the amount of damages ordered. The detailed provisions on an application for determination of damages can be found in R. 126 through R. 144 RoP. 72. As a middle road, bridging between the two alternatives outlined above |
| 119 | infringement | Binding | may order. Such award shall at least cover the expected costs of the procedure for the award of damages and compensation on the part of the successful party (R. 119 RoP). 73. It must be said that the Rules, on the face of it, treat applications |
| 19.1 | jurisdiction | Binding | 1 ANORDNUNG des Berufungsgerichts des Einheitlichen Patentgerichts erlassen am 16. Januar 2025 Einspruch bezüglich der Zuständigkeit des Gerichts (R. 19.1 VerfO) LEITSÄTZE: - Die Zuständigkeit des Gerichts (oder Jurisdiktion) beste |
| 19.1 | FRAND | Binding | BEANSTANDETE ENTSCHEIDUNG DES GERICHTS ERSTER INSTANZ Lokalkammer Hamburg, 17. November 2023, UPC_CFI_274/2023; ACT_559935/2023 STREITPUNKTE Einspruch; R. 19.1 VerfO; Zuständigkeit des EPG; Art. 32(1) EPGÜ; Festsetzung von Schadenersatz; nation |
| 118.1 | infringement | Binding | (EPG), Lokalkammer Hamburg, und beantragte die Festsetzung von Schadenersatz ge [LAST PAGES] 14 die Zahlung eines bestimmten Betrags an Schadenersatz gemäß R. 118.1 VerfO anzuordnen. Sofern der Beklagte die Verletzung einräumt, kann sich das Ger |
UPC Court of Appeal · 4
| Target | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|
| UPC_CoA_30/2024 | language regime | Binding | öer, Rechtsanwalt, Hogan Lovells International, Münich, Germany PATENT IN SUIT EP 1 740 740 LANGUAGE OF PROCEEDINGS German UPC – Court of Appeal UPC_CoA_30/2024 APL_4000/2024 2 PANEL AND DECIDING JUDGES This order has been issued |
| UPC_CoA_4000/2024 | language regime | Background | , Hogan Lovells International, Münich, Germany PATENT IN SUIT EP 1 740 740 LANGUAGE OF PROCEEDINGS German UPC – Court of Appeal UPC_CoA_30/2024 APL_4000/2024 2 PANEL AND DECIDING JUDGES This order has been issued by the second pa |
| UPC_CoA_30/2024 | language regime | Binding | chröer, Rechtsanwalt, Hogan Lovells International, München, Deutschland STREITPATENT EP 1 740 740 VERFAHRENSSPRACHE Deutsch EPG - Berufungsgericht UPC_CoA_30/2024 APL_4000/2024 2 SPRUCHKÖRPER UND ENTSCHEIDENDE RICHTER Diese Anordnu |
| UPC_CoA_4000/2024 | language regime | Background | alt, Hogan Lovells International, München, Deutschland STREITPATENT EP 1 740 740 VERFAHRENSSPRACHE Deutsch EPG - Berufungsgericht UPC_CoA_30/2024 APL_4000/2024 2 SPRUCHKÖRPER UND ENTSCHEIDENDE RICHTER Diese Anordnung wurde von dem |
courtName.other · 3
| Target | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|
| 32(1) | FRAND | Binding | E Local Division Hamburg, 17 November 2023, UPC_CFI_274/2023; ACT_559935/2023 POINTS AT ISSUE Preliminary objection; R. 19.1 RoP; jurisdiction of the UPC; Art. 32(1) UPCA; determination of damages; national patent infringement proceedings OR |
| 68(1) | procedural | Binding | brought an action against REEL before the Unified Patent Court (UPC), Local Division Hamburg, and requested determination of damages under Art. 32(1)(f) UPCA, Art. 68(1) UPCA and Part 1 Chapter 4 Rules of Procedure (RoP). Fives sought payment of da |
| 68 | procedural | Binding | nd „Rechtsordnungsshopping“ hingewiesen. Insbesondere der Wechsel von einer Reihe von Rechtsvorschriften zu einer anderen – vom deutschen nationalen Recht zu Art. 68 EPGÜ – wurde von REEL als lästig oder sogar unüberwindbar bezeichnet. 79. Obw |
UPC (CFI) · 2
| Target | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|
| UPC_CFI_274/2023 | jurisdiction | Binding | and judge-rapporteur Patricia Rombach, legally qualified judge IMPUGNED DECISION OF THE COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE Local Division Hamburg, 17 November 2023, UPC_CFI_274/2023; ACT_559935/2023 POINTS AT ISSUE Preliminary objection; R. 19.1 RoP; j |
| UPC_CFI_274/2023 | jurisdiction | Binding | tatterin Patricia Rombach, rechtlich qualifizierte Richterin BEANSTANDETE ENTSCHEIDUNG DES GERICHTS ERSTER INSTANZ Lokalkammer Hamburg, 17. November 2023, UPC_CFI_274/2023; ACT_559935/2023 STREITPUNKTE Einspruch; R. 19.1 VerfO; Zuständigkeit |
courtName.national_DE_OLG · 2
| Target | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Düsseldorf Regional Court | jurisdiction | Background | B1 (patent in suit). The patent in suit concerns a compact service module for installations for the electrolytic production of aluminum. On 9 August 2022, the Düsseldorf Regional Court issued a judgment where it established that REEL is obliged to |
| Landgericht Düsseldorf | jurisdiction | Background | tent). Das Streitpatent betrifft ein kompaktes Servicemodul für Anlagen zur elektrolytischen Herstellung von Aluminium. Mit Urteil vom 9. August 2022 hat das Landgericht Düsseldorf festgestellt, dass REEL verpflichtet ist, Fives allen Schaden zu e |
Cited by
Subsequent UPC decisions citing this case.
| Cited in | Date | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| UPC_CoA_30/2024 Court of Appeal | Jan 16, 2025 | language regime | Binding | öer, Rechtsanwalt, Hogan Lovells International, Münich, Germany PATENT IN SUIT EP 1 740 740 LANGUAGE OF PROCEEDINGS German UPC – Court of Appeal UPC_CoA_30/2024 APL_4000/2024 2 PANEL AND DECIDING JUDGES This order has been issued |
| UPC_CoA_30/2024 Court of Appeal | Jan 16, 2025 | language regime | Binding | chröer, Rechtsanwalt, Hogan Lovells International, München, Deutschland STREITPATENT EP 1 740 740 VERFAHRENSSPRACHE Deutsch EPG - Berufungsgericht UPC_CoA_30/2024 APL_4000/2024 2 SPRUCHKÖRPER UND ENTSCHEIDENDE RICHTER Diese Anordnu |
| UPC_CFI_575/2025 Mannheim LD | Feb 12, 2026 | Art. 32 UPCA / Brussels I jurisdiction | Persuasive | CoA 16 January 2025 (UPC_CoA_30/2024, Fives v REEL) |