Overview · Filed: Jul 22, 2024
UPC_CFI_414/2024
METHODS AND SYSTEMS FOR EFFICIENT NETWORK PROTECTION
InfringementMain Infringement ActionMannheim LDInfringementCase Closed
This case cites
Authorities cited within the decisions on file for this case.
Rules of Procedure · 5
| Target | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|
| 171 | infringement by equivalents — burden of substantiation | Binding | it would have been upon Claimant to substantiate in more detail, why it is of the opinion, that this is not true or relevant and point to specific facts (R. 171 RoP) |
| 30.1 | claim amendment — conditional counterclaim allowable under procedural rules | Background | such condition, which depends on internal procedural circumstances, is allowable under the Rules of Procedure, to which internal procedural conditions, which depend on the assessment of a particular question by the court, are not unknown (see e.g. R. 30.1.c, 118.2.a RoP). |
| 118.2 | claim amendment — conditional procedural acts | Background | such condition, which depends on internal procedural circumstances, is allowable under the Rules of Procedure ... (see e.g. R. 30.1.c, 118.2.a RoP). |
| 263 | claim amendment — withdrawal/amendment of case | Background | It can be left open, whether this situation falls within the ambit of R. 263 RoP or R. 265 RoP. |
| 265 | claim amendment — withdrawal of counterclaim | Background | It can be left open, whether this situation falls within the ambit of R. 263 RoP or R. 265 RoP. If regarded as a withdrawal according to R. 265.1 RoP, there is no legitimate interest of Claimant |
Cited by
Subsequent UPC decisions citing this case.
| Cited in | Date | Legal point | Strength | Excerpt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| UPC_CFI_681/2024 Munich LD | Dec 19, 2025 | conditional counterclaim — admissibility of intra-procedural condition | Persuasive | for the admissibility of such an intra-procedural condition, see also LD Mannheim, decision of 5 December 2025, UPC_CFI_414/2024 |
| UPC_CFI_628/2024 Munich LD | Jan 13, 2026 | conditional counterclaim — admissibility of intra-procedural condition | Persuasive | for the admissibility of such an intra-procedural condition, see also LD Mannheim, decision of 5 December 2025, UPC_CFI_414/2024 |