Rechtsfragen
Querschnittsansicht der Rechtsgrundsätze, wiederkehrender Argumente und des Stands der Technik, auf den sich das Gericht stützt.
Meistdiskutierte Rechtsgrundsätze
Wiederkehrende Rechtsgrundsätze über 1 Fälle mit extrahierter Begründung. Die Erfolgsquote zählt patenthalterfreundliche Ausgänge.
Häufigste zurückgewiesene Argumente
Argumente, die das UPC nicht akzeptiert hat, sortiert nach wiederholten Auftritten in Fällen.
| Argument | Partei | Fälle |
|---|---|---|
| upc lacks jurisdiction because sun patent trust seeks a frand ruling as its main claim, which falls outside upc jurisdiction | Beklagter | 1 |
| paris local division lacks internal competence because no defendant is domiciled in france | Beklagter | 1 |
| infringement is established: the accused occlusion devices fall within the scope of ep 1 998 686 b2 | Kläger | 1 |
| claim 1 lacks novelty over cited prior art range disclosures | Kläger | 1 |
| claim 1 lacks inventive step starting from d14 (float process glass) combined with d16 (refining agents) | Kläger | 1 |
| inventive step challenged by reference to chinese supreme people's court judgment on a related chinese patent | Kläger | 1 |
| experimental report d41 relevant to patentability of auxiliary requests | Kläger | 1 |
| main request (granted claims) should be maintained in full | Beklagter | 1 |
| auxiliary request i is allowable | Beklagter | 1 |
| auxiliary request ii is allowable | Beklagter | 1 |
| composition claims are novel and inventive as drafted with numerical ranges of ingredients | Beklagter | 1 |
| application to amend the patent (unconditional and subsequent auxiliary requests) | Beklagter | 1 |
| english is the commonly used language in the relevant field of technology, justifying language change | Beklagter | 1 |
| nvidia is significantly impaired in organising its defence in german | Beklagter | 1 |
| inventive step attack based on documents already in the proceedings, raised for the first time at oral hearing | Beklagter | 1 |
| counterclaim for revocation: ep 2 476 814 b1 is invalid | Beklagter | 1 |
| remaining requests in the infringement action | Kläger | 1 |
| the patent as amended (auxiliary requests ar1-ar1-24) should be maintained as valid | Kläger | 1 |
| security for costs should be set at no more than eur 100,000 and may be provided by a us bank guarantee | Kläger | 1 |
| the written witness statement of dr. raleigh qualifies as a full witness statement under r. 175 rop | Kläger | 1 |
| publication of the judgment in trade press should be ordered | Kläger | 1 |
| patent is invalid due to added matter (überschreitung der ursprungsoffenbarung) | Beklagter | 1 |
| security for costs should be ordered against 10x genomics in the provisional measures proceedings | Beklagter | 1 |
| ep 3 666 797 b1 main request and all 17 auxiliary requests are valid and inventive | Beklagter | 1 |
| literal infringement of the patent on the medical device (sleep apnea treatment) by orthoapnea and vivisol products | Kläger | 1 |
Meistzitierter Stand der Technik
Über substanzielle Hauptsachefälle herangezogene Schriften und ihre typische Rolle.
| Schriftreferenz | Vorherrschende Rolle | Fälle |
|---|---|---|
| D14 | Erfindungsmüh-Kombination | 1 |
| D16 | Erfindungsmüh-Kombination | 1 |
| D19 | Erfindungsmüh-Kombination | 1 |
| D40 (expert opinion) | Hintergrund | 1 |
| D41 (experimental report) | Hintergrund | 1 |
| D42-D45 (Chinese court judgment) | Hintergrund | 1 |
| ZP8-ZP9 (late-filed documents admitted in response to AR1-24) | Erfindungsmüh-Kombination | 1 |
| prior art starting points in the anti-PCSK9 antibody field (multiple realistic starting points identified by Central Division) | Erfindungsmüh-Kombination | 1 |