UPC_CFI_303/2024

METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR IMPLEMENTING BEARER SPECIFIC CHANGES AS PART OF A CONNECTION RECONFIGURATION THAT IMPACTS THE SECURITY KEYS BEING USED

InfringementMain Infringement ActionMunich LDInfringementCase Closed

Overview Decisions Reasoning Citations Documents Timeline

Parties

Claimants

Motorola Mobility LLC(Motorola Group)

Reps: Nina Bayerl (Freshfields PartG mbH)

Respondents

ASUSTek Computer Inc.
ASUS Computer GmbH
ASUSTEK (UK) LIMITED

Reps: Alexander Wiese (Wildanger Kehrwald Graf v. Schwerin & Partner)

Judges

Matthias Zigann
Tobias Pichlmaier
Peter Agergaard
Klaus Loibner

Patents

EP3972309SEP · LTE

CPC codes: H04L2209/80, H04W76/22, H04L9/0819, H04W12/043, H04W76/25, H04W12/041, H04W36/0038

Technology area: Telecoms · Cellular/SEP

Sector: Telecommunications

Outcome

RevokedDismissed — patent invalid

Filed: Jun 10, 2024

First decided: Oct 10, 2025

Language: German

The Munich Local Division revoked Motorola Mobility LLC's EP 3 972 309 (telecommunications patent) in full after finding added matter beyond the parent application, and dismissed the infringement action against ASUSTek, ASUS Computer GmbH and ASUSTEK (UK); costs borne by claimant Motorola.

Open on UPC Registry

Claims

At issue1, 11

Revokedall

Notes: Munich LD revoked EP3972309 in its entirety; claims 1 and 11 found to contain added matter beyond parent application, with auxiliary requests also rejected.